Skip to main content

City Council Meeting – December 10, 2019

December 10, 2019 at 11:00 AM

  • 3 h 32 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

Key Decisions

The City Council approved the consent agenda unanimously. The Council also voted unanimously to approve a Land Use Incentive Grant (LUIGI) for the Asheland/Coxe development, capped at $80,000 per affordable unit, and to approve the conditional zoning request for the same project, which included an amendment requiring the applicant to fund traffic calming measures up to $30,000; the zoning request passed on a 5-1 vote, with Councilwoman Smith voting "no." Additionally, the Council unanimously denied a request by CCC Verde Vista II LLC to utilize the LUIGI program for affordable housing and unanimously approved an $860,000 loan from the Housing Trust Fund for Asheville Area Habitat for Humanity to construct eight for-sale affordable homes. The Council also unanimously deferred consideration of a conditional zoning request for the former Sears building at One South Tunnel Road for up to 100 days.

Discussion Highlights

The meeting included a presentation by the City’s external auditors, who reported that the City received an "unmodified" or "clean" opinion on its financial statements for the year ending June 30, 2019, with no material weaknesses or fraud reported. The City Manager and the Office of Sustainability provided an update on strategic initiatives, highlighting progress toward a 100% renewable energy goal for city operations by 2030 and noting challenges in waste reduction due to population growth.

Regarding the Asheland/Coxe development, Council members debated the project’s impact on the city’s transit system, with some arguing that traffic and transit implications were a "blind spot." On the Verde Vista Phase II LUIGI request, the core issue was timing; staff recommended denial because the developer submitted the application after conditional zoning was approved, whereas updated policy requires simultaneous submission. One council member stated, "I don't believe you. I don't disbelieve you that you all were having those conversations internally. I think the rub and the problem is that that wasn't shared with us during the conversations." Another council member stated, "I probably won't be supporting this... To come after the fact and say hey we found, okay now we got the zoning, And we want Luigi now." The developer’s attorney responded, "The availability of these incentives was a key component of the developer's decision to provide the affordable housing... The policy worked exactly like it should have and its purpose should not be frustrated."

The Council also discussed a climate emergency resolution, which was removed from the agenda at the request of Sunrise Asheville to allow for further collaboration on wording. Mayor Esther Manheimer explained, "We decided we needed a little bit of more conversation to allow some time and room for the two groups [SACI and Sunrise] to come to an agreement around the wording of a final resolution... We're hopeful that you know, will happen by one of our meeting dates in January."

Community Input

During the public hearing for the Asheland/Coxe development, a public commenter expressed strong support, viewing the project as a positive step for the South Slope. Another public commenter expressed dissent, citing the project’s massive scale, removal of existing trees, and minimal stormwater management, arguing it did not meet the goals of the Living Asheville Comprehensive Plan. A third public commenter stated that excessive parking was the "elephant in the room," arguing the city should be eliminating cars rather than adding them. Another public commenter agreed with concerns about the bus system’s poor on-time performance and predicted "chaos." A fifth public commenter spoke in favor of the project’s infill nature but suggested a condition to limit parking to one space per unit. A sixth public commenter supported the project, noting the city’s progressive stance on densification.

In general public comment, a representative from a local environmental organization thanked the council for approving funding for urban forestry analyses and announced a goal to plant 50,000 trees by 2040. When asked how residents could report trees planted on their own property, she stated they could contact the organization and she would consider how to collect that information. A representative from a local advocacy group clarified that the climate resolution was removed from the agenda at their request to continue working on wording. A resident of West Asheville advocated for declaring a "real" climate emergency. A 32-year-old trans woman stated that the climate emergency is already here and urged the council to pass the Sunrise-drafted resolution. The Health Coordinator for a local movement explained that the version of the resolution on the agenda was not endorsed by their group and requested immediate public input sessions.

A former Asheville Fire Department employee spoke in defense of a Division Chief, alleging a pattern of misconduct by the Fire Chief. A staff member responded, "Obviously, this is a personnel matter, so none of us can comment in any way. But of course, we have... staff here who have listened to you and so thank you." A public commenter expressed frustration regarding truck enforcement on residential streets; no council member or staff member responded to this specific comment. A representative from a local economic organization expressed disappointment that transit numbers promised for December were not provided and asked the council to bring a budget amendment in January; no council member or staff member responded to this specific request. A public commenter reminded the council that it was International Human Rights Day; no council member or staff member responded to this specific comment.

Follow-ups

The Mayor and Council agreed to allow the Sustainability Advisory Committee and the Sunrise Movement more time to finalize the wording of the climate emergency resolution, with the item expected to return to the agenda in January 2020. The City Manager agreed to send transit numbers to Council members. The developer of the Asheland/Coxe development agreed to fund traffic calming measures on Morgan Street if deemed necessary by the neighborhood and city processes. The Executive Director of Asheville Greenworks stated she would "put some more thought into how we can collect" information on trees planted by residents on their own properties.

Impact

These decisions impact residents by advancing a mixed-use development that includes affordable housing and traffic calming measures, while denying a separate affordable housing grant request due to procedural timing issues. The approval of the Habitat for Humanity loan supports the construction of eight for-sale homes for low-income households. The deferral of the former Sears building zoning request allows for further review, and the delay of the climate emergency resolution indicates that the City will continue collaborating with community groups on specific language and accountability timelines before taking further action on climate policy.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches