City Council Meeting – November 26, 2019
November 26, 2019 at 11:00 AM
- 1 h 44 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
City Council Meeting Recap: November 26, 2019
The Asheville City Council convened on November 26, 2019, to address a range of agenda items including routine approvals, public hearings on zoning and street closures, and open public comment. The meeting concluded with the council entering a closed session to consult with the city attorney regarding legal claims.
Key Decisions and Votes The council approved the consent agenda, with the removal of items F1 and F2, by a motion that was made, seconded, and passed with ayes recorded and no opposition. The council also adopted resolutions to permanently close three unopened rights-of-way: Lenox Court, and the pair of Pond Street (corrected from Pond Road) and Lance Lane. All three closure motions were made, seconded, and passed with ayes recorded and no opposition. In a significant zoning decision, the council voted to deny proposed amendments to Article 8 of the Unified Development Ordinance (UDO) that would have permitted campgrounds and accessory dwelling units in the Highway Business Zoning District. The motion to deny the amendments, finding them inconsistent with the city’s comprehensive plan, was made, seconded, and passed with ayes recorded and no opposition. Finally, the council passed a motion to enter closed session to consult with the city attorney regarding the settlement of claims involving Mayfair Partners LLC and Gwen Alexander.
Discussion Highlights: Zoning and Tiny Homes A major portion of the discussion centered on the denied zoning amendments, which were intended to formalize tiny home living. The petitioner for the change explained that the "campground" category is the only available tool to permit tiny homes and requested that staff be empowered to write rules for small, safe housing units. Another commenter provided data indicating it takes an average Asheville resident approximately 26 years to save for a conventional home down payment, compared to 3.7 years for a tiny house. Staff clarified that while the city has no minimum size requirement for homes, units occupied for more than 180 days must be built under the North Carolina State Building Code or certified through HUD, and "tiny homes on wheels" are regulated as recreational vehicles by the DMV rather than as housing.
Council members expressed mixed views on the one-off zoning change. One council member stated they would not support the specific amendment until the issue is examined in a "larger context," but expressed interest in staff exploring the "tiny homes on wheels" model for affordability, noting, "I would very much like for staff to continue to take a look at this... I do think it is an option that we need to explore." Another council member commended the petitioner’s creativity but disagreed with the one-off change, asking the petitioner to continue keeping in contact with staff and other council members. Mayor Esther Manheimer noted that a tiny home on wheels is similar to a DMV-titled mobile home, which depreciates in value, and stated, "I'm glad we're looking at the possibility" of incorporating this model, though she indicated she did not know enough to say if it was a good idea.
Community Input: Safety, Wildlife, and Climate Public comment addressed several distinct issues. Regarding the Riverside Drive railroad crossing, a representative from a local cycling advocacy group argued the current design creates an "unsafe condition" for northbound cyclists, describing the proposal as a "safety third approach." A second commenter from the same group read survey responses detailing injuries, including broken bones and concussions, at the crossing. In response, a council member noted that staff has proposed a European-style solution to smooth railroad tracks to Norfolk Southern, which the railroad has not adopted, and urged the community to "continue to be creative and patient." Mayor Manheimer acknowledged the input, stating, "I appreciate Asheville on Bikes coming tonight. I've definitely heard from bikers myself... about having accidents at this location."
On wildlife issues, a representative from a wildlife advocacy group reported that at least a dozen black bears in the Asheville area have suffered amputation injuries from illegal snare traps and requested that the council liaise with state officials to stop the maiming. No specific member response to the bear trapping comments was recorded. Regarding veteran support, a caregiver requested that the city sign a resolution to become an "Elizabeth Dole Hidden Hero City." Mayor Manheimer stated that the resolution calls for actions the city does not currently provide but noted existing partnerships with the VA.
Finally, multiple commenters from the Sunrise Movement requested that the council pass a specific climate emergency resolution as written and vote on it at the December 10 meeting. One council member stated, "I for one support that [the climate emergency resolution coming to council agenda on December 10]." Mayor Manheimer explained that the city received an email from the Sunrise Movement stating there is an "impasse in communications" with the city’s sustainability committee (SACI). She noted that the resolution is a template not tailored to Asheville and lacks specific calls for funding the city’s existing environmental plan, stating, "I am hopeful that we can figure out a way to make this work because it certainly should not be adversarial." Another council member stated that SACI "continues to be open to discussions" and would prefer the resolution to work its way through the regular process with SACI support.
Follow-ups Staff agreed to continue looking at the tiny homes on wheels model in the context of affordability, involving zoning, development, and affordable housing departments. Mayor Manheimer agreed to follow up with staff to review what the city is already doing regarding veteran support and what the proposed resolution entails. Additionally, Mayor Manheimer stated she would be available to talk after the meeting regarding the climate resolution and its alignment with the city’s existing environmental plans.
Impact on Residents The denial of the Highway Business zoning amendments means that campgrounds and accessory dwelling units are not currently permitted in that district, though staff will continue to explore the "tiny homes on wheels" model for affordability. The permanent closure of Lenox Court, Pond Street, and Lance Lane removes these unopened rights-of-way from the public map. The council’s engagement with the Sunrise Movement and the cycling advocacy group indicates ongoing deliberation regarding the city’s approach to climate policy and infrastructure safety, with the climate resolution scheduled to appear on the council agenda on December 10.
Meeting Video & Transcript