City Council Meeting – September 24, 2019
September 24, 2019 at 11:00 AM
- 3 h 55 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
City Council Meeting Recap: September 24, 2019
The City of Asheville City Council held a regular meeting on September 24, 2019, addressing a wide range of items including zoning hearings, a hotel moratorium, affordable housing policy, and election charter amendments. The council voted on several key measures, with significant public input received on environmental, housing, and governance issues.
Key Decisions and Votes The council approved the consent agenda without recorded opposition. In zoning matters, the council denied the conditional zoning request for a mixed-use development at 72 Broadway, citing that the project did not meet comprehensive plan goals for a diverse mix of uses and that access was insufficient. The council approved the rezoning of a half-acre parcel at 940 West Chapel Road from Neighborhood Business to Residential Single-Family High Density (RS-8), finding it consistent with the comprehensive plan. Additionally, the council approved the rezoning of a 3.7-acre parcel at 9999 Lakeside Drive from Residential Single-Family Medium Density (RS-4) to Residential Multifamily Medium Density (RM-8) to support infill development and environmental benefits.
The council unanimously adopted an ordinance imposing a temporary moratorium on new hotel development approvals, effective September 24, 2019, and expiring no later than September 24, 2020. Council members noted the one-year duration was chosen to ensure the moratorium could survive legal challenge. The council also unanimously passed a resolution adopting the policy "Policies for Implementing Affordable Housing on City-Owned Land." This policy establishes a baseline that at least 20% of units on redeveloped city-owned land must be affordable to households at 60% of the Area Median Income (AMI) and accept Housing Choice Vouchers, with a minimum affordability period of 20 years and a goal of 30 years. Finally, the council appointed James Poole to the city-appointed seat on the Buncombe County Tourism Development Authority (TDA) board, selecting him over the other applicant.
Discussion Highlights A significant portion of the meeting was dedicated to the election charter amendments, which were not voted on but scheduled for the next meeting. Council Member Vijay Kapoor proposed that the Office of Equity and Inclusion review the issue using an equity lens before a vote, stating, "I think we're missing a great opportunity in Asheville and I don't think we're living up to our true progressive potential in this city." Council Member Keith Young responded to Kapoor’s comments, stating, "I take extreme exception to the comments made by Councilmember Kapoor... complete political puffery." Young argued that the African American community had already spoken via the referendum and that the at-large system works for them, adding, "The system that we have in place that we're fighting for, the at-large system, is equally powerful in getting people on council as it has to keep people off council." Mayor Esther Manheimer stated that the Council needs to be responsive to voters who want to restore what Raleigh took away and suggested that, for constituent services purposes, Council might consider assigning members to different parts of the city to ensure clear entry points for residents.
Regarding the hotel moratorium, Mayor Esther Manheimer stated that the Council is "challenged to move forward in a very strategic and purposeful way" and that they are "expected to come out of this with some sound policy." She specifically mentioned exploring the intersection of hotels, displacement, and housing, adding, "We're going to roll up our sleeves and do what we need to do to make good, meaningful policy." Council Member Keith Young agreed that "failure is not an option" and noted that the City Manager would not let them fail. He also reminded the public that a separate process is currently underway by the TDA for their Tourism Management and Investment Plan (TMIP), encouraging residents to participate via AshevilleCVB.com/TMIP.
On the affordable housing policy, Council Member Sheneika Smith acknowledged the desire for longer affordability terms but explained the "financial reality" that the current policy represents the maximum leverage possible, stating, "I have to trust their [staff's] recommendation... it is not what I want it to be... but we can't fight the financial framework here." Council Member Julie Mayfield noted that the policy pushes the limits of what is realistic, warning against "unintended consequences" of perpetual deed restrictions.
Community Input Public comment was extensive across multiple agenda items. On the consent agenda, a public commenter representing the Sunrise Movement argued that deferring the climate emergency declaration means it is not treated as an emergency, calling for a 100% renewable energy goal. Another resident read a statement by Greta Thunberg, criticizing the council for focusing on economic growth while ignoring the climate crisis. No specific member replied to these comments; the chair moved the meeting forward.
For the 72 Broadway project, a representative for the Asheville City Market confirmed no construction would occur during market hours. A representative for the owners of 52 Broadway Street expressed concern about alley safety and requested written commitments. A resident from North Asheville echoed the request for written answers regarding alley use and traffic. A representative from ImageJetworks Architecture argued that the community’s critical needs are a working-class tax base and mixed-use development, urging the council to approve the project. No specific member replied to these comments; the chair noted a motion to deny was pending and proceeded to the vote.
On the 940 West Chapel Road rezoning, a representative for the Shiloh Community Association requested to see all plans and expressed concern about design and traffic. Council Member Keith Young suggested that the developer and community association work together to create a cohesive vision. The applicant agreed to work with the community, and the association representative agreed, stating they just want to be a good neighbor.
Regarding the hotel moratorium, a public commenter expressed concern that the moratorium might delay a specific proposal for the Lee Walker Heights property, which includes 80 units of affordable housing. Another public commenter argued that allowing hotels to be the "highest bidder" hollows out the downtown core. A public commenter asked Council to approach the moratorium from a comprehensive land-use perspective, urging the use of the moratorium year to conduct "strategic pilots" on affordable housing criteria.
On the election charter amendments, a public commenter supported a compromise between district and at-large systems. Another expressed frustration with the "cynical" nature of the referendum, arguing that nine council members is "too many cooks in the kitchen." A public commenter from Public Interest Projects supported Council Member Vijay Kapoor’s proposal for a combination of five districts and four at-large seats. A public commenter emphasized the importance of maintaining the "pick three" voting structure. Another suggested looking into alternative voting methods like ranked-choice voting.
On the affordable housing policy, a public commenter urged Council to aim for affordability periods longer than 20 years, suggesting 50 years or perpetuity.
On tree preservation, a public commenter representing approximately 500 residents called for stricter tree policy enforcement, citing the recent cutting of 80-year-old trees at the YWCA. Members did not respond to this comment.
On transit, a public commenter expressed frustration that the extension of evening bus hours was delayed until January due to capacity issues. Council Member Julie Mayfield stated that staff are working on the benchmarks and that the Council will have something in a couple of weeks.
Follow-ups The council will proceed with the one-year moratorium period to conduct studies on tourism impacts, infrastructure, and housing. The ordinances to revert to at-large elections and reinstate a primary will be voted on at the next meeting on October 22, 2019, without an additional public hearing. Staff are currently developing specific capacity benchmarks for the extension of evening bus hours, with an update expected in a couple of weeks.
Impact These decisions have immediate implications for Asheville’s development and governance. The hotel moratorium pauses new hotel approvals for one year, allowing the city to study the industry's impact on housing and infrastructure. The affordable housing policy sets a precedent for future development on city-owned land, mandating a minimum percentage of affordable units. The denial of the 72 Broadway project signals a stricter review process for mixed-use developments that may not align with comprehensive plan goals or provide adequate access. The upcoming vote on election charter amendments will determine the structure of the city's council elections, a topic that generated significant debate regarding representation and equity.
Meeting Video & Transcript