Skip to main content

City Council Meeting – September 10, 2019

September 10, 2019 at 11:00 AM

  • 3 h 57 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

City Council Meeting Recap: September 10, 2019

The City of Asheville City Council held a regular meeting on September 10, 2019, addressing a wide range of agenda items including a proclamation for National Suicide Prevention Week, a consent agenda, two public hearings on zoning requests, a proposed hotel development moratorium, charter amendments, and a climate emergency resolution. The meeting featured significant public input on development projects and infrastructure, with the Council taking action on several items while deferring others for further review.

Key Decisions and Votes The Council voted to approve the consent agenda, which included routine items and the Charlotte Street Road Diet project. Prior to the vote, staff clarified that while the road diet includes resurfacing and catch basin reconstruction, full-scale stormwater improvements are not currently funded in the Capital Improvement Plan but are identified for future study. The vote passed with "aye" votes recorded and no opposition. In a separate public hearing, the Council voted to approve the rezoning of two lots at 120 and 9999 Emma Road from Residential Single-Family Low Density (RS2) to River Arts District Open Space (RAD OSP), along with an amendment to the Future Land Use Map. This motion also passed with "aye" votes and no recorded opposition.

Regarding the "Create 72 Broadway" mixed-use development at 72 Broadway Avenue and 61/67 North Market Street, the Council voted unanimously to continue consideration of the project to the next council meeting on September 24, 2019. The project was neither approved nor denied at this meeting; the continuation allows the developer to discuss access and market issues with neighbors and the farmers market. The Council also voted unanimously to set a public hearing for September 24, 2019, regarding a temporary moratorium on new hotel development. This vote only sets the date for the hearing; the moratorium itself will be voted on at a future meeting. Additionally, the Council unanimously adopted resolutions of intent to consider two charter amendments: one for at-large elections and one for conducting City Council elections via the nonpartisan primary and election method. Public hearings for both amendments were set for September 24, 2019. Finally, the Council voted unanimously to enter closed session to consult with the City Attorney regarding the lawsuit Carrier Riverview Incorporated, et al. v. City of Asheville and to consider personnel matters.

Discussion Highlights During the discussion on the charter amendment for at-large elections, a commenter argued against the system, citing voter registration data that suggested it would dilute the African American vote, as Districts 2 and 5 contain 60% of the African American registered voters. The commenter warned this could lead to a lawsuit by the NAACP Legal Defense Fund. In response, Council Member Keith Young spoke in favor of a mixed system (5 districts + 2 at-large seats) rather than a full at-large system, arguing this would ensure accountability for all neighborhoods. Regarding the primary election amendment, staff explained that state statutes define the timetable for even-year primaries, making it impossible to hold them later in the year. When asked about the Board of Elections' capacity, Mayor Esther Manheimer stated, "I don't know, there's a lot more than federal elections on the ballot right now."

On the hotel development moratorium, Mayor Esther Manheimer stated, "I'm totally in support of this moratorium. I wish that we had done it two years ago... I think we waited too long and let too many hotels be built before getting to this point." During the 72 Broadway hearing, Vice Mayor Gwen Wisler expressed concern about access issues, stating, "I do have serious concerns about the access issues... It doesn't... guarantee that there won't be a collision of interests... So I am also going to be a no vote." Regarding the climate emergency resolution, staff stated the resolution will go through the Sustainable Asheville Climate Initiative (SACIE) committee, as accelerating commitment to clean energy is a conversation that needs to start there, and it is expected to be addressed in October.

Community Input Public comment was extensive, particularly regarding the 72 Broadway development and the Charlotte Street Road Diet. For the Road Diet, a representative from the Grove Park and Sunset Mountain Association requested the suspension of the project pending a professional traffic engineering study, citing a 2013 city study that concluded the lane reduction fails safety criteria. The Transportation Director responded by explaining the project follows Complete Streets policy and that "before and after" studies will be conducted in the first year to monitor success. Another resident asked the Council to delay expenditure to assess the cost of repairing Old Toll Road, which is suffering from landslides; no direct response was recorded.

For the 72 Broadway project, numerous public commenters spoke. Several farm vendors and market representatives opposed the project, with one stating it would be the "death of Asheville City Market" and another highlighting the loss of 240 market jobs versus the 45 jobs created by the project. A property owner on 56 Broadway opposed the alley access plan, describing the alley as already congested and unsafe. Conversely, several residents and business owners supported the project, citing good aesthetics, housing for downtown workers, and the argument that the parking lot will eventually be developed anyway. One real estate professional warned that relying on the alley for access during market hours "just won't work." A resident suggested creating a "community table" or forum for developers to engage with the community before spending significant funds. The Council did not directly respond to most of these individual comments, though the decision to continue the item to the next meeting was made.

Follow-ups Staff indicated that the climate emergency resolution will go through the Sustainable Asheville Climate Initiative (SACIE) committee and is expected to be addressed in October. No other specific follow-ups were explicitly agreed to by members or staff during the meeting.

Impact These decisions impact residents through changes to land use, traffic management, and local governance. The approval of the Emma Road rezoning converts residential land to open space, while the deferral of the 72 Broadway project leaves the fate of the downtown farmers market and surrounding infrastructure pending further review on September 24. The upcoming public hearings on the hotel moratorium and charter amendments will determine whether new hotel construction is temporarily halted and how City Council elections are structured, potentially affecting representation and local development patterns.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches