Skip to main content

Human Relations Commission – August 15, 2019

August 15, 2019 at 6:00 PM

Recap readyAdd to calendar
Next: Feb 18, 2021 meeting
  • 2 h 23 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

Human Relations Commission Meeting Recap: August 15, 2019

The Human Relations Commission of Asheville convened on August 15, 2019, to review previous records and discuss the development of a written consent policy for vehicle searches. The meeting also featured introductions of the City Manager and the newly appointed Chief of Police, as well as a broad discussion on police department priorities, community engagement, and the dissemination of public safety information.

Key Decisions The commission approved the minutes from the previous meeting. No formal vote was taken to adopt the written consent policy, as the item is currently in the drafting and feedback stage. Additionally, a motion was made and seconded to move the discussion and amendment of the work plan to the next meeting, which is scheduled for September 18. The meeting was subsequently adjourned.

Discussion Highlights The primary focus of the meeting was the mechanics, training, and timeline for implementing a written consent policy for vehicle searches. City Manager Deborah Campbell described the policy as a "tool" to begin building trust, noting that it is "not really a panacea" for improving accountability. Chief of Police Chris Bailey emphasized that simply putting a policy on paper does not solve underlying issues, stating, "It does not teach our officers how they're expected to act... So there has to be training involved in that."

The Chief of Police outlined six broad priority areas for the Asheville Police Department (APD), including improving community relations, reducing crime and fear, and supporting officer wellness. A representative from the Asheville-Buncombe County NAACP presented concerns regarding the potential resistance from the Fraternal Order of Police (FOP), the need to expand the policy to pedestrians, and the necessity of outside monitoring for body camera footage. In response, the City Manager stated that the department is committed to a holistic approach.

Discussion also addressed the importance of providing context to public information regarding crime, particularly gang activity and property crimes. A speaker with a background in public information noted that the city has a "robust system in place" that will continue to improve, emphasizing that the focus should be on training to keep youth out of gang-related situations rather than instilling unnecessary fear.

Community Input Several members of the public provided comments during the meeting. One commenter asked if the written consent policy would reduce negative interactions and potentially lower homicide rates. Chief Bailey responded that he wants to "increase the positive interactions" but stated, "I can't answer the question right now because I just don't think there's data to be able to defend the next one."

Another public commenter, identifying as a pedestrian frequently stopped by police, urged the commission to include pedestrians in the consent policy, noting that a vehicle-only policy leaves vulnerable people unprotected. The Chair acknowledged the comment, and the City Manager explained that the initial policy applies only to legal vehicle stops to allow for a "test drive" before expanding to pedestrians or property. A third commenter representing a community organization for homeless individuals argued that the Fourth Amendment protects personal space for those without homes and also urged the inclusion of pedestrians. The Chief of Police discussed the need for engagement centers and support services for the rising homeless population but did not explicitly commit to expanding the written consent policy to pedestrians at this meeting.

A public commenter asked if the high rate of traffic stops of Black residents was a sign of implicit bias. Chief Bailey stated, "I wish I had a definitive answer for you, but I just don't... That's my commitment is to try to do our very best to figure out what exactly that is." Another commenter, a parent and veteran, expressed concern about how officers interact with children and suggested the APD administer implicit bias tests. The chair summarized this as a request for community engagement and cultural sensitivity training, but no specific member or staff member provided a detailed policy response or commitment to implement the suggested tests during the recorded portion of the transcript.

Follow-ups Chief Bailey stated he has received feedback from officers and the FOP and will make "a few small structural changes" to the written consent policy draft, including improvements to the form and data tracking methods. He confirmed that training is a prerequisite for implementation and indicated that training would include topics on traffic stops, racial bias, de-escalation, and the law. The Chief also stated he has spoken with the IT department about ways to track consent data to provide transparency to the community. When asked for a timeline, the Chief stated, "I can't give you the timeline. I would like it as soon as possible." The chair stated that commission members would populate the notes from the public comments and provide them later.

Impact This meeting highlights the city's ongoing efforts to address trust and accountability between the police department and the community. The discussion underscores that the written consent policy is viewed as one component of a broader strategy that includes training, data tracking, and community engagement. The commission’s decision to defer the work plan to September 18 indicates that strategic planning for these initiatives is still in progress.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches