Skip to main content
  • 1 h 32 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

Human Relations Commission Meeting Recap: February 18, 2021

The Human Relations Commission of Asheville held a virtual meeting on February 18, 2021, to address internal business, staff updates, and the formation of work groups for the upcoming year. The agenda focused primarily on the transition of the Office of Equity and Inclusion, the development of 2021 work plan priorities, and a significant debate regarding the Vance Monument. The meeting concluded with the adjournment of the session.

Key Decisions The only formal vote taken at this meeting was to adjourn. A motion to adjourn was made, seconded, and passed via roll call, with all present commissioners voting "Yes." No other motions were voted on. Specifically, a motion to have the Vance Monument Task Force present to the Commission on March 18, 2021, was proposed but subsequently rescinded by the mover before a vote could occur.

Discussion Highlights Staff provided an update on the Office of Equity and Inclusion, noting that Richard White is serving as the interim director and that the office is continuing work on the Equity Action Plan, racial healing grants, and equity budgeting. The Commission discussed forming small, non-quorum work groups to draft the 2021 work plan, with members expressing interest in focusing on the Vance Monument, homelessness and encampment removal, and contracting disparities.

A significant portion of the meeting was dedicated to the Vance Monument. Vice Chair Dolores Williams-Venable proposed a motion for the Task Force to present to the Commission on March 18, 2021, prior to the City Council vote scheduled for March 23, 2021. She stated, "I don't want to sit out here and blindly make a decision that represents other people when other people don't know." However, she rescinded the motion "for the sake of the board" and to maintain a working relationship, noting for the record that she disagreed with making decisions without full information.

Commissioner Tanya Rodriguez argued that writing a letter of recommendation in support of removing the monument would add weight to the decision, stating, "That thing needs to come down now." Conversely, Commissioner Davidson Jones cautioned against assumptions, asking, "Can we assume that everybody on the commission here wants a monument down?" Acting Chair Tiffany Flannery-DeBelow expressed discomfort with voting on the issue without more information, stating she would prefer to see input from members with specific interests before the Commission takes next steps.

City Attorney Brad Branham provided guidance on Open Meetings Law compliance, advising that work groups must remain below quorum size (seven or fewer members) to avoid violations. He clarified that while members may share drafts via email for information purposes, they must wait until a full public meeting to deliberate and vote on any proposals or letters.

Follow-ups Richard White, Interim Director of the Office of Equity and Inclusion, agreed to contact the chairs of the Vance Monument Task Force to determine when the final report would be available, stating, "as soon as we get that, we can send it on to you all as well." He also confirmed that the City Manager is working on a cost determination and repurposing plan for the Vance Monument site, which is expected to go back to City Council on March 23, 2021. Commissioner Susie Chandler indicated an interest in forming a work group around homelessness and encampment removal, while Commissioners Chris Weinbrenner and Veronica expressed interest in spearheading efforts related to the Vance Monument, potentially through a small work group or drafting a letter of recommendation.

Impact This meeting established the framework for the Commission’s 2021 activities, specifically the creation of small work groups to address local equity issues. While the Commission did not take a formal position on the Vance Monument at this session, the discussion highlighted the need for further information and internal deliberation before the City Council votes on the issue in March. The legal guidance provided ensures that future work groups operate in compliance with Open Meetings Law, requiring public deliberation for any final actions.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches