City Council Meeting – May 28, 2019
May 28, 2019 at 11:00 AM
- 5 h 1 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
City Council Meeting Recap: May 28, 2019
The Asheville City Council convened on May 28, 2019, to address the Fiscal Year 2019-2020 Operating Budget, zoning changes, and facility naming rights. The meeting began with recognitions, including a Neighborhood Hero Award for a resident of the Shiloh community and proclamations for Jane’s Walk Month, Pollination Celebration Month, and Hemp History Week. Staff reports highlighted the financial independence of the Asheville Regional Airport, which reported 1.13 million passengers and $12.4 million in operating income, as well as updates on the In Real Life after-school program and the Charlotte Street road diet project, which is expected to enter construction in fall 2019.
The Council voted unanimously to pass the consent agenda and to continue the public hearing for One South Tunnel Road to July 23, 2019. A significant portion of the meeting was dedicated to the proposed $190.3 million operating budget, which includes no increase in the property tax rate. The budget proposes a 2.5% across-the-board pay raise and a $1.56 million increase in transit investment, adding 20,000 service hours. Staff noted challenges in fully funding the Transit Master Plan due to revenue limits and bus shortages. The City Manager confirmed that the budget will be brought back for final adoption on June 11, 2019.
Regarding zoning, the Council unanimously recommended approval for the Verde Vista Phase 2 project, a 56-unit apartment building. The motion was amended to include a condition requiring 10% affordable housing (6 units) for 20 years. The City Attorney will wordsmith this condition. Additionally, the Council voted unanimously to enter a closed session to consult with the city attorney regarding a potential lawsuit, PSG, Asheville LLC v. City of Asheville.
The most contentious decision of the evening involved the naming rights for the Civic Center. The Council debated a 10-year offer from Harrah’s Cherokee (with a 5-year extension option) against a 3-year offer from U.S. Cellular. Staff explained that rejecting both offers would incur approximately $200,000 in branding removal costs and require the city to fund the venue’s debt service of approximately $170,000 annually from the general fund. In a roll call vote, the motion to accept the Harrah’s Cherokee offer passed, with all members voting in favor except for one member who voted against. Staff will initiate steps to enter into a naming rights license agreement with Harrah’s Cherokee.
Public comment addressed several key issues. Residents and representatives from "Better Buses Together" and the Amalgated Transit Union Local 128 urged the Council to fully fund the Transit Master Plan, specifically requesting extended evening and Sunday service. One resident stated he would be walking 3.2 miles home because the last bus leaves at 7:15 PM. Mayor Esther Manheimer acknowledged the desire for expansion but cited financial limitations, stating, "I will not renew that suggestion" regarding a property tax increase. Council Member Gwen Wisler noted that total transit funding, including federal and license revenue, is over $10 million. Firefighters and the Firefighters Association cited difficulty in recruiting and retaining staff due to low starting wages, requesting adjustments to market value. No specific member responded directly to these comments.
On the Civic Center naming, public comment was divided. Supporters of Harrah’s Cherokee cited inclusivity and the financial necessity for facility renovation, while opponents argued that gambling does not reflect community values. Council Member Julie Mayfield voted against the motion, arguing that neither offer was "culturally and socially compatible" with Asheville’s identity. Council Member Keith Young supported the Harrah’s proposal, citing the "incredibly generous payments" needed for renovations, and Council Member Brian Haynes argued there is no "moral superiority" between beer and gambling brands. Mayor Esther Manheimer stated she was looking forward to voting for the Harrah’s proposal, emphasizing the need for creative funding to maintain facilities.
The Council also voted via voice vote with no recorded opposition to solicit public input on naming the police headquarters at 100 Court Plaza in memory of former Lieutenant Walter Robertson, the first Black lieutenant in the Asheville Police Department. Council Member Keith Young stated that the request to name the headquarters would be put on the agenda for a public hearing at the next council meeting.
Several follow-up actions were agreed upon during the meeting. Staff will direct a consultant to provide recommendations and costs for implementing a $31,200 annual minimum salary for permanent full-time employees, with an expected completion date of December/January. Staff will also renegotiate the consultant contract for the Charlotte Street project to include an assessment of the road diet’s performance within the first year of operation. The City Attorney will finalize the language for the affordable housing condition for Verde Vista Phase 2, and staff will begin the process of entering into the naming rights agreement with Harrah’s Cherokee.
Meeting Video & Transcript