City Council Meeting – May 14, 2019
May 14, 2019 at 11:00 AM
- 4 h 20 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
City Council Meeting Recap: May 14, 2019
The City of Asheville Council met on May 14, 2019, to address the proposed Fiscal Year 2019-2020 Annual Operating Budget, a public hearing regarding the renovation of the historic Flatiron Building, and various administrative matters. The meeting included proclamations for Tick-Borne Diseases Awareness Month and National Public Works Week, as well as the awarding of the G. Herbert Stout Award for Visionary Use of GIS to the city for its "Mapping Racial Equity" application.
Key Decisions and Votes The council unanimously adopted the consent agenda. Three appointments to fill vacancies were approved: Robert Hooper to the Community Planning Advisory Committee (CPAC), Parker Smith to the Historic and Architectural Commission (HIAC), and Ivan Melkor to the Human Relations Commission. A motion to allocate $7,900 for Councilmember Keith Young’s participation in a Harvard University public policy implementation certificate program failed. No vote was taken on the Fiscal Year 2019-2020 Budget or the Flatiron Building renovation, as the former is scheduled for a public hearing on May 28, 2019, and official adoption on June 11, 2019, while the latter was withdrawn by the applicant.
Budget Discussion City Manager Deborah Campbell and Assistant Director of Finance Tony McDowell presented a proposed budget of $190.3 million, representing a 5.4% increase over the current year. The General Fund is $132 million, up 6.3%. The property tax rate remains at 42.89 cents per $100 of valuation, with revenue growth driven by a 3% increase in the property tax base and 9% year-over-year sales tax growth. Funds are allocated for insourcing sidewalk and stormwater crews, updating fire department equipment, expanding police body and vehicle cameras, and a 2.5% employee raise effective July 2019. The Capital Improvements Plan includes $8 million for Fire Station 13 construction, $500,000 for computer replacements, and $200,000 for facility maintenance. During discussion, Councilmember Keith Young suggested using part of the cost-of-living adjustment to raise lower-wage employees to $15/hour, but City Manager Campbell recommended against a piecemeal adjustment, citing an ongoing comprehensive compensation study. Councilmember Julie Mayfield asked for clarification on General Fund figures, which were provided by staff.
Flatiron Building Public Hearing Planning staff presented a proposal to convert the 1926 Flatiron Building into a hotel with 80 lodging rooms and ground-floor retail space. Applicant representatives Wyatt Stevens and building owner Russell Thomas argued that the building requires approximately $10.5 million in repairs for life safety and infrastructure that cannot be economically sustained under its current office use. Following extensive public comment, the applicant’s representative withdrew the application, stating they would reach out to opponents to explore alternative solutions for saving the building. Mayor Esther Manheimer noted that the city is at a point where it needs to develop a comprehensive way to weigh hotel applications against broader community concepts.
Community Input Public commenters expressed opposition to the Flatiron Building project, citing gentrification, displacement of local businesses, increased traffic, and the saturation of downtown with hotel rooms. Others supported the project, arguing it is the only viable option to save the building due to necessary safety upgrades. A resident expressed frustration over unmitigated truck traffic on Maxwell Street, and another expressed disappointment that the city did not support her application for the HUD Youth Homelessness Demonstration Program grant. No council or staff response was recorded for the Maxwell Street or Youth Homelessness comments.
Follow-ups The City Manager’s office will conduct a comprehensive compensation and classification study, with results expected in time for the FY 2021 budget. Staff are meeting with Homeward Bound, the county, and other partners to structure a team to assist people experiencing homelessness, focusing on the upcoming tourist season. The applicant for the Flatiron Building agreed to reach out to opponents to explore alternative solutions. Following the failed vote on the Harvard funding, the council directed the Governance Committee to comprehensively review the travel policy, including educational opportunities and conference coverage.
Impact The proposed budget maintains the property tax rate while funding existing services with minor enhancements, including a 2.5% employee raise. The withdrawal of the Flatiron Building application leaves the future of the historic structure unresolved, with the applicant now exploring alternative solutions with community opponents. The failure of the Harvard funding motion prompted a review of the city’s travel policy to determine how best to support council members' professional development.
Meeting Video & Transcript