City Council Budget Work Session – February 12, 2019
February 12, 2019 at 11:00 AM
- 44 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
City Council Budget Work Session Recap: February 12, 2019
On February 12, 2019, the City Council of Asheville held a closed work session to review the Capital Improvement Program (CIP) and the ongoing budgeting process. The session was informational in nature, with no votes taken or motions made. City Manager Deborah Campbell and Chief Financial Officer Barbara Whitehorn presented an update on capital investments, providing context for upcoming budget decisions.
The presentation began with a historical review of the city’s capital investment strategy, noting a shift from a "pay-as-you-go" cash model to a debt-financing model to leverage funds more effectively. Staff provided an overview of ongoing projects funded by the 2016 Geo-Bond referendum, including road improvements, traffic calming, and bus shelters. A map was presented overlaying capital projects with areas of high poverty to demonstrate the equitable distribution of investments across the community.
A significant portion of the discussion focused on the gap between current funding and departmental needs. CFO Barbara Whitehorn highlighted that while the current CIP contains $60 million in projects, departments have requested $330 million to meet desired service levels and infrastructure quality standards. Whitehorn stated, "Requested by the departments was $330 million worth of projects. The total in our current CIP is $60 million. So we have a pretty significant... gap there." She further explained that the annual allocation for resurfacing is about $3 million, which brings the Pavement Condition Index (PCI) to 61, noting that additional funding of $16 million would only result in a marginal improvement.
Council members discussed specific high-cost unfunded needs, including the replacement of the transit maintenance facility, full transit service expansion, the Thomas Wolfe Center renovation, and greenway system expansions. One Council Member expressed concern over historical underinvestment, stating, "It shocks me in terms of just looking at like the lack of debt... historically, I can understand the conservative nature of it, but we're paying for that now. It's penny wise, pound foolish... we're dealing with that right now is how to basically fund what wasn't funded in years past." Another Council Member noted, "This is not a new story. We're just putting it on slides right now... I think it helps focus budgeting decisions when you know that this is out there and it needs to be addressed."
Regarding the $50 million cost for the transit maintenance facility replacement, a Council Member suggested that federal dollars might cover a significant portion, stating, "My understanding is... a significant chunk of this would be paid for with federal dollars... maybe even up to... 10 million or less... I don't know that we need to be planning for 50 million for this facility because there are federal dollars." In response, CFO Whitehorn clarified, "We have no current plan in place... Even if we set aside money every year, it would be probably well over a decade before we could save enough to get to a place where we could build it." City Manager Campbell concluded the discussion by stating, "We've got some tough decisions that we need to make over the next several years... I believe that as we focus and prioritize that we will be able to chip away at this task."
Staff agreed to several follow-up actions requested by Council members. CFO Whitehorn agreed to provide a detailed list of the projects comprising the $330 million in departmental requests, including identification of where grants are anticipated to impact the numbers. She also agreed to identify potential funding sources for major unfunded projects, such as grants, partnerships, and eligible debt types like Limited Obligation Bonds, Special Obligation Bonds, or Geo-Bonds. Staff committed to evaluating options for the transit maintenance facility replacement, including studying the required size, location, and potential use of federal grant dollars to offset the $50 million cost.
City Manager Campbell stated that staff will continue to review and develop a recommended CIP. Council will review this in draft form in March and April, leading to budget adoption in May or June. Campbell described the current information as "introductory food for thought," indicating that a deeper dive will occur at the Council retreat in March. There were no public comments during this closed work session.
Meeting Video & Transcript