Skip to main content

City Council Meeting – December 11, 2018

December 11, 2018 at 11:00 AM

  • 2 h 59 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

City Council Meeting Recap: December 11, 2018

The City of Asheville City Council held a regular meeting on December 11, 2018, addressing a range of administrative, financial, and development issues. The agenda included updates on the city’s response to recent severe weather, the status of affordable housing projects, and several public hearings regarding economic development incentives and zoning changes. The council also reviewed the city’s fiscal year 2018 financial audit and authorized modifications to existing loan agreements.

Key Decisions

The council took action on several major items during the meeting. The consent agenda was approved. Regarding development incentives, the council approved a resolution authorizing a performance-based economic development agreement with Burial Beer Company, LLC. In a significant zoning decision, the council voted to deny the conditional zoning request for a 170-room hotel (RB Hotel) at 62 Fairview Road. The denial was based on non-compliance with lot frontage standards, a 100-foot setback inconsistent with active streetscape goals, and existing saturation of hotels in the Biltmore Village area. Additionally, the council authorized the City Manager to modify a 2013 Section 108 loan to disburse the remaining $450,000 to Eagle Market Street Development Corporation (now Eagle Market Place Commercial LLC) and approved a corresponding budget amendment of $450,000 to fund this disbursement. Two public hearings were continued: the hearing for a proposed 56-room hotel on Biltmore Avenue was continued to March 26 at the applicant’s request, and the hearing for Item D was continued until January 22.

Discussion Highlights

The meeting opened with the Mayor welcoming new City Manager Deborah Campbell and thanking staff for their response to the recent snowstorm, referred to as "Snowmageddon." Fire Chief Scott Burnett reported that the city experienced 47 vehicle collisions during the snowfall but no loss of life, noting this was significantly lower than typical collision rates for a normal day.

On the financial front, the city received an unmodified opinion for its fiscal year 2018 audit. Robbie Bittner, Senior Audit Manager at RSM, stated, "I'm happy to say that the city did receive an unmodified opinion for this year... There's nothing here that indicates any kind of fraud, waste, or abuse." The Chief Financial Officer assured the council that a corrective action plan is being implemented to address two significant deficiencies related to financial statement closing and cutoff timing, with procedures expected to be in place by the end of the year.

Regarding the Art Space Affordable Housing Project, staff presented a feasibility study identifying three potential city-owned sites: Riverside Drive, South Charlotte Street, and Biltmore Avenue. Mike Marcus of the Center for Craft noted that Asheville received the second highest number of responses in Artspace's history, trailing only Los Angeles. Staff recommended moving forward with a Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) with private partners to allow them to submit a proposal for evaluation within the next 18 months, clarifying that this does not commit the city to developing the project with ArtSpace.

In the discussion on the RB Hotel denial, a council member highlighted that the Biltmore Village area already has seven hotels, stating, "I feel the same way about this [as I did about the airport road hotel]... I'm not going to be in support of this." Another council member commented on the scale of development, saying, "This does not in my mind look like what a town center should look like... If you don't have enough land to do the kinds of things that we're looking at doing, you need to figure that out."

For the Eagle Market Street loan modification, the CEO of Eagle Market Street Development Corporation explained, "In order for us to be profitable, we can't throw the baby out with the bathwater... We need to keep the rates in a way that would be able to [meet debt service]... That is all I am asking of you." A council member emphasized the project's intent, stating, "The spirit and intent of this project itself was to revitalize the area... If you don't see minority business here... if you don't see this place kind of spring up from the ashes and reconnect with the East End community... then you're just contributing to what already is." Another council member added, "I think we all here on the dais want this project to succeed... I think that we as a council... will see what the market will bear... I'm gonna be supportive of this."

Community Input

Public comment was received on several agenda items. Regarding the Burial Beer Company incentive, a representative from the Economic Development Coalition supported the grant, noting its alignment with the city’s strategic plan for high-wage employers.

For the 62 Fairview Road hotel, an adjacent property owner supported the project, citing potential foot traffic. The owner of 4 Fairview Road supported the project for area revitalization but requested enforcement of the 25 mph speed limit on Fairview Road for safety. A public commenter expressed concern that "Opportunity Zone" designations should ensure ownership opportunities for low-income residents, not just employment. A Southside resident highlighted traffic saturation near the Biltmore House and the lack of walkable connections to nearby businesses.

On affordable housing, a resident questioned if the current 80% Area Median Income (AMI) target is sufficient, requesting that plans for South Charlotte and Biltmore sites go lower to 50% AMI and include voucher housing. A council member confirmed that all city-invested housing is required to accept vouchers, while the Chair noted high construction costs require significant subsidies. A Kenilworth resident urged the council to engage with grassroots community members rather than relying solely on top-down planning, expressing concern over the displacement of people of color. Another commenter addressed a newly elected council member regarding electoral structure, arguing against the narrative of "racial gerrymandering" by citing strong vote totals across all districts. A council member responded that the current representation of African Americans on the council is an anomaly not seen in 25 years.

Follow-ups

Staff and members agreed to several specific follow-up actions. For the Art Space project, staff will work on an MOU with private partners. For the Biltmore Avenue affordable housing site, staff will return to the council in January with an implementation plan, including a Request for Qualifications (RFQ) to line up developers. For the South Charlotte Street site, staff plan to release an RFQ to conduct a facilities study to determine the cost and method for relocating current facilities. For the Riverside Drive site, staff are negotiating an MOU to allow proposals from qualified developers for affordable artist live-workspaces. The Neighborhood Advisory Committee (NAC) Chair agreed to gather information on how residents want to be informed and participate in city issues. Regarding the sign ordinance, a council member suggested placing the issue of neighborhood welcome signs on the agenda for the new City Attorney to review. Finally, the City Manager is authorized to execute the Eagle Market Street loan modification and disburse the funds.

Impact

These decisions impact residents through changes in local development, public safety, and financial stewardship. The denial of the 170-room hotel at 62 Fairview Road reflects the council's stance on hotel saturation in the Biltmore Village area, prioritizing streetscape goals and frontage standards over additional lodging capacity. Conversely, the approval of the Burial Beer Company incentive and the Eagle Market Street loan modification supports continued economic activity and commercial revitalization in specific districts. The progress on the Art Space affordable housing project indicates a commitment to addressing housing needs at three city-owned sites, with specific next steps for developer engagement and facilities studies. The unmodified audit opinion, coupled with the corrective action plan for identified deficiencies, provides assurance regarding the city's financial integrity.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches