Skip to main content

City Council Budget Work Session – November 27, 2018

November 27, 2018 at 11:00 AM

  • 1 h 1 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

City Council Budget Work Session Recap: November 27, 2018

The Asheville City Council held a closed work session on November 27, 2018, to review the city’s revenue sources and address the financial challenges associated with its growing daytime population. The meeting focused on a presentation by Interim City Manager Kathy Ball, who outlined the constraints the city faces in balancing service costs with current revenue streams. No formal votes were taken during the session, but the Council reached a consensus to direct staff to further explore specific revenue options and engage with the community.

Key Decisions and Consensus The Council did not pass any formal motions or make binding decisions on new taxes. However, after reviewing the financial data, Council members indicated a consensus to move forward with deeper research and community engagement regarding the proposed revenue options. The Chair noted that the city is "limited in our tools" to specifically tax visitors, stating, "We don't have a scalpel to try to tax visitors... So we're trying to find the tools that best are reapportion the tax burden for folks living and visiting in Asheville."

Discussion Highlights Interim City Manager Kathy Ball explained that the city’s current revenue growth—approximately 3% for property taxes and 5% for sales taxes—is insufficient to cover rising costs for employee raises, healthcare, inflation, and construction. This shortfall leaves a deficit of approximately $400,000 in the base budget before accounting for deferred maintenance. Ball highlighted a significant imbalance: while a large portion of city services, such as streets, fire protection, and greenways, are utilized by non-residents, the costs are primarily borne by property-owning residents. She noted that the city’s daytime population doubles from approximately 90,000 to 160,000 when tourism is included.

Ball presented three potential revenue options to address this imbalance, noting that all would require action beyond the City Council’s unilateral authority:

  1. Quarter-Cent Sales Tax for Transit: A countywide tax requiring a voter referendum and approval by the Buncombe County Commission, with revenue dedicated to transit operations and infrastructure.
  2. Prepared Food and Beverage Tax: A citywide tax (e.g., 1%) on prepared food and beverages, which would require new enabling legislation from the North Carolina General Assembly and a voter referendum.
  3. Hotel Tax (TPDF): Staff clarified they are not proposing an increase to the hotel tax for general city use. Instead, they are working with the Tourism Development Authority (TDA) to fund a $50 million, 10-year program for downtown improvements, including sidewalks, placemaking, and the Thomas Wolfe Auditorium, using existing Tourism Product Development Fund (TPDF) money.

Council members expressed mixed but generally supportive views on exploring these options. One member noted that tourism is "still to some degree a seasonal thing here... It's not like the commuters where the number is regular every day." Another member pointed out the limitations of the transit tax, stating, "We don't get to do that [the transit tax]. The county commission has to vote to put it on the ballot. We can ask them to do that, but they can say no." Despite these hurdles, members expressed support for continuing the conversation, with one stating, "I'm interested in moving the conversation forward... it's definitely worth moving the ball forward and with the sobering understanding that there is no clear pathway forward right now, but we will see what comes of it."

Follow-Ups Based on the consensus to proceed, staff outlined several next steps to be undertaken:

  • Transit Master Plan: Staff will work with the county to update the Transit Master Plan to identify how improvements could be made into the county.
  • Community Engagement: Staff will engage with local partners, including the Asheville Independent Restaurants, Asheville Area Chamber of Commerce, Council of Independent Business Owners, Asheville Lodging Association, and Asheville Bed and Breakfast Association, to discuss the potential impacts of the proposed taxes.
  • Legislative Action: Staff will direct legal counsel to inform lobbyists to begin conversations with the North Carolina General Assembly regarding enabling legislation for a city-only prepared food and beverage tax.
  • Equity Analysis: Staff will conduct further research to quantify the specific financial impact of the proposed taxes on low-income households and families, including comparing the impact of a quarter-cent sales tax versus a 1% food and beverage tax.
  • Alternative Tax Structures: Staff will investigate the feasibility of splitting the food and beverage tax to tax only beverages (or alcoholic beverages) rather than food, to mitigate impacts on low-income residents.
  • City-Only Transit Tax: Staff will investigate the logistical and legal feasibility of legislation that would authorize the city alone to enact a transit tax, bypassing the need for a countywide referendum.

Impact on Residents This work session highlights the ongoing tension between the city’s role as a regional hub and the financial burden on local taxpayers. By directing staff to explore these options and conduct equity analyses, the Council is seeking to understand how to more fairly distribute the cost of services that benefit both residents and visitors. The upcoming engagement with business partners and legislative lobbying efforts will determine the viability of these revenue streams in the coming months.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches