City Council Budget Work Session – November 13, 2018
November 13, 2018 at 11:00 AM
- 1 h 27 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
City Council Budget Work Session Recap: November 13, 2018
The City of Asheville City Council held its fourth budget work session on November 13, 2018, focusing on informational presentations from four department directors regarding their operational challenges, budget needs, and strategic goals. The session served as a closed work session between council members and staff, with no public comments recorded. No motions were made, and no votes were taken during this portion of the meeting.
Capital Projects and Development Services Jade Dundas, Director of Capital Projects, presented on a department established in the winter of 2016–2017 in response to a bond referendum. The department has grown from 10 to 15 staff members and manages the full lifecycle of capital projects. Dundas noted that the department charges $1.16 million in staff costs back to specific projects, resulting in a net operating impact of approximately $313,000. She highlighted significant challenges with contractor availability, stating, "The first time in my career I've experienced zero bids was last summer. So contractor availability is a bit of a concern." To address this, the department is shifting its bidding schedule to winter and using a real-time financial dashboard, viewed by approximately 550 people monthly, to keep the public informed.
Ben Woody, Director of Development Services, discussed a department designed as a single point of contact for development applications, comprising 58 full-time equivalents. Woody reported that in FY18, the department opened nearly 10,000 records and performed over 52,000 inspections. He noted that salaries and benefits account for 92% of the budget, with revenue being volatile due to the cyclical nature of construction. Woody observed, "The data says development's slowing. I don't think it's free-falling, but I think it's going to level out to probably what is going to be the real normal." Key goals include creating a digital permit process, which is expected to roll out for residential permits in January, and expediting reviews for council priority projects such as affordable housing.
General Services and Public Works James Ayers, Director of General Services, presented on a department with 42 staff members across five divisions. Ayers stated that 83% of the general fund budget is allocated to salaries and benefits. He reported that Phase one of the facilities condition assessment is complete, creating a database to predict maintenance needs year-by-year for Capital Improvement Plan submissions. Ayers emphasized, "We actually have a database now where we can actually go out and predict what do we need year by year so we can plan those investments in the future." The department aims to develop a facilities master plan, a real estate master plan, and update fleet policies to align with renewable energy goals.
Greg Schuller, Director of Public Works, discussed a department managing multiple funds, including the General Fund and Stormwater Enterprise Fund. Schuller noted that operating costs are high, accounting for 48% of the General Fund budget, driven by the cost of equipment, concrete, and asphalt. He reported that the city’s Pavement Condition Index (PCI) is currently 60 out of 100, stating, "Our PCI is really nothing to brag about right now. It's about a 60 out of a hundred... It would take consistent funding at $5 million per year for our PCI to remain stable." Schuller also highlighted an "all-time low" in contractor capacity, noting, "I have over 30 years in this business and I've never seen it like it is [regarding contractor capacity]... We also are seeing contracts that we don't have anybody to bid on or we have one person to bid on."
Follow-ups and Next Steps During the Q&A portion of the meeting, several follow-ups were identified. In response to a council question regarding discrepancies in benefits percentages across departments, a staff member stated, "we'll get you that information" and "we'll provide you that information" to clarify the comparison of salaries and benefits. Director James Ayers stated that a staff report regarding the potential in-housing of custodial services for remote sites will be brought to council in the December timeframe. Additionally, Assistant City Manager Ben Woody noted that the county has completed a paying class salary compensation study, which the interim county manager will share with the city the next day. He noted the city may come back to council to discuss amending agreements with the county’s consultant to cover city positions not currently included, as the city is losing employees to the county due to pay differences.
Meeting Video & Transcript