Skip to main content

City Council Meeting – November 27, 2018

November 27, 2018 at 11:00 AM

  • 2 h 2 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

City Council Meeting Recap: November 27, 2018

The Asheville City Council held a meeting on November 27, 2018, to address a variety of local issues including transportation, equity, and public safety. The agenda included the approval of a consent agenda, presentations on health and business disparities, a new ordinance regarding electric scooters, and a detailed discussion on parking enforcement. The meeting concluded with the Council moving into a closed session to consult with the city attorney on a lawsuit and to discuss personnel matters.

Key Decisions The Council voted to approve the consent agenda, which included a resolution regarding the I-26 Connector project and a Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) with Homeward Bound for housing at 29 Oak Hill Drive. The vote was unanimous, with all members in favor and none opposed. Councilmember Julie noted that the I-26 resolution serves to thank the Department of Transportation (DOT) but emphasizes that the city is "not done yet" because DOT has not yet committed to adopting the recommendations in the Schwartz Report. Regarding the MOU, Councilmember Julie stated it is a "great step" to continue conversations without committing the city to specific funding.

The Council also voted to adopt a new ordinance regulating e-scooters, specifically Chapter 19, Article 1, Section 19-16 of the Code of Ordinances. This ordinance includes a moratorium on the use of e-scooters and imposes $100 fines for violations. The vote was unanimous, with all members in favor and none opposed. Finally, the Council voted unanimously to enter a closed session to consult with the city attorney regarding the lawsuit Custodial Law Enforcement Recording Sought by the City of Greensboro and PHG Asheville LLC v. City of Asheville, to consider the qualifications and performance of a public officer or employee, and to prevent the disclosure of information confidential under the Personnel Privacy Act.

Discussion Highlights Staff and consultants presented findings from a disparity study on minority and woman-owned business participation in city contracting. The presentation highlighted significant disparities, particularly in non-construction contracts. Councilmember Young stated, "I’ll cut to the chase about the numbers, they suck. Especially as it pertains to the black folks and African-Americans with these contracts." He suggested placing the disparity study under the oversight of the Department of Equity and Inclusion and the Human Relations Commission. The Mayor responded that she would defer to the new City Manager to evaluate this organizational structure when they arrive the following week.

The Council also discussed the Transit Master Plan, focusing on the $3 million required for the first year of service increases. Assistant Director of Transportation Jessica Morris noted that it is "challenging" to start service enhancements on July 1st without a recent budget commitment. A council member, identifying as the Council’s most vocal transit advocate, expressed doubt that a July 1st start was a realistic expectation given that funds are typically allocated in the budget process and take six months to plan. Staff clarified that services are typically rolled out in January because of the six-month planning period, apologizing for setting the July 1st expectation.

Regarding parking enforcement, the Council discussed a specific incident involving a blue truck parked on the sidewalk on Maxwell Street. A council member questioned the parking supervisor, asking why they did not issue a ticket, and noted, "I'm just trying to figure out, you already stated that, you were told not to take that blue truck." The discussion focused on the communication between city staff regarding the enforcement of that violation.

Community Input During public comment, residents raised several concerns. A public commenter representing a local Black Lives Matter chapter urged the Council to move forward with new police policies and not "take two steps back." Another public commenter asked the Council to apply an "equity lens" to all decisions, noting that less than $2 million in contracts went to people of color-owned businesses while over $116 million went to white-owned businesses. In response, Councilmember Young suggested placing the disparity study under the oversight of the Department of Equity and Inclusion.

On the e-scooter ordinance, a public commenter representing Venture Asheville argued that e-scooter companies create local jobs, urging the Council to be progressive. Another resident argued that fines should only apply to the company, not individual users. A downtown resident raised safety concerns, stating, "I heard nothing about safety... I would rather have autonomous vehicles than someone who may not have a brain riding one of these scooters down the street." The Mayor responded by stating that Asheville is "not interested in another company coming here and using our community for their purposes" unless the product serves as a transportation solution for locals. Councilmember Young commented, "I actually like the scooters... I think it’s interesting... I think we need to be more forward-thinking and get ahead of the curve on some of these things."

A public commenter expressed frustration with traffic delays related to the Bowen Bridge construction. The Mayor stated, "We can get an update about the project and update our website to let people know the new timeline." Another public commenter presented data arguing that state-mandated district maps do not constitute racial gerrymandering and asked the Council to reconsider bringing a lawsuit against the state; no specific member replied to this comment. A public commenter alleged they were terminated for false reasons; a staff member stated they were "happy to look into this and meet with you." Finally, a public commenter requested "equity of enforcement on Maxwell Street" and a copy of an email regarding the blue truck; no council member or staff member responded to this specific request in the transcript.

Follow-ups Staff member Brenda Mills stated that internal staff meetings would begin to look at the "bare bones" of the disparity study plan, followed by a public comment process, noting, "We’re looking at another couple of months before you see that come back to you." The Mayor agreed to have staff get an update from the DOT on the Bowen Bridge project and update the city website with the new timeline. A staff member agreed to look into the personnel matter raised by a public commenter and meet with the complainant. Staff member Jessica Morris noted that the Council needs to commit budget for the Transit Master Plan service increases soon, as the contractor needs time to prepare for a July 1st start date. Staff member Tim Putnam stated that the bike share consultant is willing to conduct a more in-depth study on e-scooters, but the city is currently trying to find the budget for that additional cost.

Impact These decisions and discussions have direct implications for residents. The adoption of the e-scooter ordinance will immediately regulate the presence of these vehicles in the city, prioritizing safety and local transportation needs over corporate deployment. The disparity study findings highlight significant inequities in city contracting, prompting a review of how the city supports minority and woman-owned businesses. The transit discussions underscore the financial and logistical challenges of implementing the Transit Master Plan, with a focus on securing the necessary $3 million for service increases. The parking enforcement review aims to clarify communication and consistency in how violations are handled in residential areas.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches