Skip to main content
  • 4 h 36 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

City Council Meeting Recap: June 19, 2018

The Asheville City Council held a regular meeting on June 19, 2018, addressing a comprehensive agenda that included the adoption of the FY 2018-19 operating budget, the Living Asheville Comprehensive Plan, and significant policy changes regarding police equity and transparency. The council also voted on various land use decisions, infrastructure agreements, and appointments to city boards and commissions.

Key Decisions and Votes The council unanimously passed the Consolidated Annual Action Plan for 2018-19, the land use incentive grant for the Sweetgrass Apartments project, and rezoning requests for 339 West Haywood Street and 9999 Kemp Street. The Living Asheville Comprehensive Plan was also adopted unanimously. Regarding the FY 2018-19 Operating Budget, a motion was made to adopt the ordinance with staff-noted changes, and a hand-raise vote was taken; however, the final tally or outcome was not recorded in the transcript before the council moved to closed session. The council unanimously passed three resolutions related to the Asheville Police Department (APD) regarding written consent for searches, criteria for consent searches, and deprioritizing low-level regulatory vehicle stops. Additionally, the council unanimously approved the transfer of sublease rights for the Grove Arcade to Grove Arcade Asheville LLC, adopted the city’s Equity Action Plan, and authorized the Mayor to execute a water production and distribution agreement with Henderson County. All motions for board and commission appointments were passed with no recorded opposition.

Discussion Highlights The adoption of the FY 2018-19 Operating Budget featured significant debate over police funding and resource allocation. One council member voted against the budget, arguing that resources should be directed toward free transit or de-prioritizing low-level offenses rather than increasing police officer funding. Another council member voted in favor, citing the need for more officers to handle service calls and violent crime. In response to public concerns about police expansion, the Vice Mayor noted that the Transit Master Plan recommends a pilot for fare-free weekends rather than immediate 24/7 fare-free service due to bus maintenance constraints.

Regarding the APD Equity and Transparency Resolutions, Councilmember Kapoor addressed officer safety concerns by stating that a written consent policy with no exceptions for verbal consent could endanger lives in domestic violence scenarios, though he clarified he supported the resolution because it leaves specific policy development to the Chief of Police. Councilmember Young rejected the argument that rights should only be exercised when "safe and practical," stating, "My rights are always practical." The Vice Mayor noted that the council does not draft police policy, but rather the Chief and City Manager will do so. Councilmember Smith requested that the City Manager ensure the final policies reform the original intent of the motions passed in May.

Community Input Public commenters raised several issues during the meeting. Regarding the Living Asheville Comprehensive Plan, one commenter objected to the plan’s objectives, arguing they interfere with the affordable housing market, while another read a poem praising the vision but stating they could not support the current budget. Council members thanked planning staff for their outreach efforts and noted the plan honors the council's 2030 vision.

During the APD resolutions, numerous commenters urged the council to reaffirm the May 22 vote, citing a lack of trust and historical racial profiling. Representatives from police unions argued the resolution language was "unrealistic" in dangerous situations and requested the addition of the phrase "when safe and practical." Personal testimonies included accounts of police violence, such as a woman describing being thrown into a vehicle and a tree worker describing being beaten.

Other public comments included concerns about city bus safety, with a resident reporting injuries from drivers departing before passengers were seated; no council members or staff responded to this comment. Regarding homestay permits, a resident and a representative for permit holders requested that the council reconsider the January 2018 ordinance requiring the removal of kitchenette sinks. In response, one council member stated that the item must go through the Planning, Engineering, and Development (PED) department first to get direction from the Council. A staff member clarified that existing permit holders are grandfathered under non-conformity provisions.

Follow-ups The council agreed to send the homestay ordinance issue to the PED department, where staff will provide a report on the rationale and options, including information on the number of permits and the impact on existing holders. The Transportation Department Director stated that the consultant’s draft summary of recommendations for the I-26 Connector would be submitted for review before being sent to the DOT in early July, and the city would extend the call for applications for the Aesthetics Committee. The Equity Core Team plans to provide progress reports to the Council on a quarterly basis. The City Manager is authorized to execute documents for the Grove Arcade sublease transfer, and the Chief of Police and City Manager are responsible for drafting the specific policies based on the adopted APD resolutions.

Impact These decisions establish the city’s financial priorities for the coming year and formalize its long-term planning vision through the Living Asheville Comprehensive Plan. The adoption of the APD resolutions signals a shift in police policy toward greater transparency and accountability, with specific policy details to be developed by the Chief of Police and City Manager. The approval of the Henderson County water agreement expands the city’s water production and distribution capabilities, while the Grove Arcade sublease transfer ensures the continued operation of a key downtown historic building. The Equity Action Plan provides a strategic framework for advancing inclusion in workforce, contracting, and economic opportunities.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches