City Council Meeting – May 22, 2018
May 22, 2018 at 11:00 AM
- 5 h 5 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
City Council Meeting Recap: May 22, 2018
The Asheville City Council convened on May 22, 2018, to address a wide-ranging agenda that included police accountability, the Fiscal Year 2018-19 Operating Budget, zoning requests, and proposed state legislation. The meeting opened with the approval of a proclamation designating June 4–10, 2018, as Vegan Challenge Week, presented by Council Member Brian Haynes, and the presentation of the Volunteer of the Year award to Renee White. Both items passed unanimously. The council also approved the consent agenda, though the process involved a procedural debate regarding an open data resolution that was ultimately removed from the consent agenda and moved to the regular agenda.
A significant portion of the meeting was dedicated to police accountability and data transparency. Presenters from the NAACP and the Southern Coalition for Social Justice highlighted data showing that in 2017, the Asheville Police Department (APD) recorded its most racially disparate stop and search numbers in 15 years, with Black drivers comprising 24% of stops and 46% of searches. Chief Tammy Hooper responded by stating that APD would not adopt a written consent policy, arguing that body-worn camera footage provides a sufficient record of voluntary consent. Despite the Chief’s stance, the Council voted to direct the City Manager to require written consent for vehicular and personal property searches, prohibit basing consent searches solely on prior criminal records or suspicious behavior, and deprioritize low-level regulatory stops. All three motions passed. Additionally, the Council voted unanimously to support the release of data sets presented by Code for Asheville, subject to legal and personnel confidentiality requirements.
The Council also addressed the Fiscal Year 2018-19 Operating Budget during a public hearing, where no final votes were taken; the final vote is scheduled for June 19. Public commenters expressed mixed views on the APD budget increase, with some citing unimplemented recommendations for racial disparity training and others defending the department’s role in combating the opioid epidemic. The President of the Asheville Firefighters Association requested an increase in the 457 retirement match from 4% to 6% to match other city employees, noting that firefighters do not receive Social Security. Representatives from the Asheville Museum of Science (AMOS) requested budget support, noting that AMOS receives only 3.5% of its revenue from local government compared to a 24% national average. Concerns were also raised regarding the lease for McCormick Field, noting that the city invested $765,000 in a building that had decreased in value and that the $10 million asset had no active lease after December 31, 2016.
On the zoning front, the Council unanimously passed recommendations for three public hearings: the rezoning of a parcel on Founders Drive for a UNCA multi-purpose building, the rezoning of 39 Bradley Branch Road for the Sweet Grass Apartments (a 248-unit multifamily complex including affordable housing), and an amendment to the conditional zoning ordinance at 301 East Chestnut Street to allow a full-service restaurant at the Princess Anne Hotel. The Council also unanimously approved a resolution directing the interim manager and Chief Financial Officer to complete limited obligation bonds financing, which includes $23 million in geo-bond anticipation notes and $48 million in limited obligation bonds for construction projects.
The Council discussed three pieces of proposed state legislation to be sent to the state delegation: allowing citizens to know the outcome of complaints filed against officers, allowing Council and a potential Citizen Review Board to view body camera footage under confidentiality agreements, and repealing the Civil Service Board to replace it with a Citizen Review Board with subpoena power and binding disciplinary authority. All three recommendations passed unanimously. However, the Chair noted that local bills in a short session require unanimous support from the state delegation, which may not be achievable for the Civil Service repeal bill. The Council also unanimously approved HCD Committee recommendations for the Strategic Partnership Fund, funding 19 agencies out of 21 applications with a total budget of $242,500.
Regarding board appointments, the Council agreed to re-advertise for two openings on the Board of Adjustment. For the Homeless Initiative Advisory Committee, the Council voted unanimously to interview two candidates for one opening. The Council also unanimously approved the appointment of 14 individuals to the Human Relations Commission. The meeting concluded with a unanimous vote to enter a closed session to consult with the City Attorney regarding privileged information and real property acquisition negotiating positions.
Follow-ups Staff agreed to meet with external stakeholders, including Code for Asheville, to finalize parameters for releasing the remaining two data sets (use of force and location data) to ensure ongoing criminal investigations are protected. Chief Hooper stated that the next quarterly traffic stop report will include the top 10 locations where Black drivers are stopped, that supervisors will audit every body-cam video associated with a consent search, and that the department will review consent search forms to remove "prior criminal record" and "nervousness" as bases for consent. The HCD Committee agreed to re-examine and potentially update the Land Use Incentive Grant (Luigi) criteria. Staff offered to provide a report detailing AMOS’s work with local social service agencies for Council review. The Council requested follow-up via email regarding the lease on the former McCormick Field. The Council will send the three legislative recommendations to the state delegation.
Impact These decisions establish new directives for police conduct regarding consent searches and data transparency, aiming to address documented racial disparities in traffic stops. The approval of interim debt financing authorizes the city to proceed with construction projects, while the budget hearing sets the stage for a final vote on the operating budget in June. The zoning approvals facilitate new housing and commercial developments, including affordable housing units and a new restaurant. The proposed state legislation seeks to increase transparency in police accountability and modify the disciplinary structure for city employees, though its passage in the state legislature is uncertain.
Meeting Video & Transcript