Skip to main content

City Council Special Called Meeting - March 5, 2018

March 5, 2018 at 11:00 AM

  • 22 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

City Council Special Meeting Recap: March 5, 2018

The Asheville City Council held a special called meeting on March 5, 2018, to address the aftermath of the August 25, 2017, arrest of Johnny Rush by Asheville Police Department (APD) Officer Christopher Hickman. The agenda focused exclusively on this incident, covering an official apology, the legal steps required to release additional evidence, and the authorization to disclose personnel records related to the officer’s conduct and subsequent resignation.

Key Decisions The Council voted to enter a closed session to consider personnel matters, consult with the city attorney, and plan the release of confidential information. During the vote, the Chair confirmed that the Council would return to open session to read a statement. While the transcript records "Aye" responses, it does not explicitly state the final tally or if any members voted "No." Following the closed session, the City Manager presented a resolution concurring in the release of personnel information. The City Manager stated that the Council had "acted upon a resolution" and that the document was "read and approved, adopted this fifth day of March 2018." This resolution authorized the release of a six-page memorandum detailing the timeline of the incident, the administrative investigation, and the officer's resignation.

Discussion Highlights The City Council Chair issued a formal apology, stating, "On my behalf and on behalf of City Council we apologize to Mr. Rush for his experience with City Police Officers this summer." The Chair also explained the legal constraints regarding evidence, noting, "Today the city attorney filed a lawsuit on behalf of the city council seeking to make public any additional videos of the incident... under the state law we cannot... make them public unless we get a court order." The City Manager emphasized the department's stance on accountability, stating, "The community deserves to know that the City takes Hickman's misconduct seriously and that APD employees who engage in excessive force will be held accountable." The Chair encouraged residents to review the released documents, adding, "I would encourage you to give it full consideration. Yes, it's available online."

The released memorandum outlines the procedural history of the case. It notes that on August 25, 2017, APD received a complaint from Mr. Rush, leading Chief Hooper to suspend Officer Hickman’s law enforcement authority. On September 15, 2017, District Attorney Todd Williams agreed to dismiss all charges against Mr. Rush after reviewing the footage. Administrative investigations concluded between December 15 and 17, 2017, that Hickman engaged in excessive force and rude conduct on four other occasions. A pre-disciplinary conference was held on January 2, 2018. On January 5, 2018, Chief Hooper met with Hickman to inform him of her decision to terminate his employment; however, Hickman elected to resign before the written decision was presented. Between January 10 and 12, 2018, the District Attorney requested the State Bureau of Investigation (SBI) to investigate potential criminal assault, but the SBI declined, citing the completion of the internal investigation. On January 18, 2018, Chief Hooper assigned a separate criminal investigation to APD’s Criminal Investigation Division, as administrative findings cannot be used for criminal prosecution.

Community Input No public comments were taken during the meeting. The Chair explicitly stated, "we are not taking public comment tonight," noting that only some members of the press were present. The Chair encouraged residents to attend the upcoming Citizens Police Advisory Committee (CPAC) meeting to speak directly with Council members.

Follow-ups The City Manager agreed to provide a copy of the detailed memorandum and timeline to the public and to post it on the city’s website. The City Attorney filed a lawsuit on behalf of the City Council on the afternoon of March 5, 2018, to seek a court order for the release of additional body-camera videos. The City Council stated they would be in attendance at the CPAC meeting scheduled for that Wednesday at 6:30 PM at the Wesley Grant Center to hear from community members. Additionally, the City Manager stated that APD expected to submit the criminal investigation file to the District Attorney "within the next week" to determine if criminal prosecution would be pursued.

Impact This meeting resulted in the official release of internal police records regarding the arrest of Johnny Rush, providing the public with a detailed timeline of the administrative and criminal investigations. The Council’s decision to file a lawsuit to compel the release of additional body-worn camera footage indicates that further evidence may become public once a court order is obtained. The release of these documents and the upcoming CPAC meeting serve as the primary channels for community engagement and transparency regarding this specific incident.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches