Skip to main content

City Council Meeting - February 27, 2018

February 27, 2018 at 11:00 AM

  • 1 h 44 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

City Council Meeting Recap: February 27, 2018

The Asheville City Council held its regular meeting on February 27, 2018, addressing a range of topics including proclamations, legislative updates, and public safety. The agenda included routine consent items, a presentation on water and sewer regionalization, an update on the North Charlotte Street Innovation District, and a resolution regarding gun violence prevention. The council also received general public comment on various local issues before moving into a closed session to consult with the city attorney.

Key Decisions The council voted on three specific motions during the open session. A motion was made and seconded to approve the consent agenda; the vote was taken and passed unanimously, with all members voting in favor and none opposed. Similarly, a motion was made and seconded to approve the Gun Violence Prevention Resolution, which called on Congress and state legislatures to prioritize student safety and enact an assault weapons ban. This motion also passed unanimously. Finally, a motion was made and seconded to enter a closed session to consult with the city attorney regarding privileged and confidential information, which also passed unanimously.

Discussion Highlights A significant portion of the meeting was dedicated to a presentation by State Representative Chuck McGrady on the Joint Committee to Study Rates and Transfers of Public Enterprises. Representative McGrady discussed the representation of the Metropolitan Sewer District (MSD) and regionalization efforts, stating, "I have absolutely no interest in going down that road [seizing Asheville's water]... I do not expect I will have any legislation having to deal with Asheville's water system." He emphasized that his constituents were paying higher rates and were unrepresented on the MSD board, adding, "I tried to do this in an open fashion, and I now need your help because, again, I don't want to go back and just impose something." Mayor Esther Manheimer expressed a desire for de-escalation, stating, "I would look for us to find a place where we're not fighting about this anymore would be my hope." Council Member Julie Mayfield noted, "We have been acting under a looming threat since I've been in office since 2009... I would say we're at a calmer time period than we have been before."

Regarding the Gun Violence Prevention Resolution, Mayor Manheimer stated, "I personally am pretty tired about the political tension around this issue [gun violence] and would hope that the Congress would act immediately to re-institute the ban on assault weapons." Council Member Mayfield highlighted the limitations of local authority, noting that North Carolina cities have "very limited authority" over gun control due to state preemption laws. She expressed frustration with the national conversation, stating, "I'm personally fairly exasperated about the conversation that doesn't have anything to do with guns... But it is because of the NRA and its influence that politicians are not able to make a decision that otherwise represents of the majority of the population."

Staff also provided an update on the North Charlotte Street Innovation District, covering the corridor from Biltmore Avenue to Edwin Street, including safety improvements and planning next steps. Additionally, the council adopted proclamations designating March 10, 2018, as Zelda Fitzgerald Day and March 19–25, 2018, as Asheville Climate Week, as well as a resolution in memory of Reverend Billy Graham.

Community Input Public comment was received on several topics. Regarding the water and sewer study, a public commenter from Woodfin urged Representative McGrady to pursue cooperation rather than force, while another from Southwest Asheville criticized the committee as a vehicle for legislative overreach, stating, "If it ain't broke don't fix it." A third commenter noted that courts had previously ruled the 2013 water bill unconstitutional. Council members did not directly rebut these specific criticisms in the transcript, though Mayor Manheimer and Council Member Mayfield had engaged in a Q&A with Representative McGrady prior to public comment.

On the gun violence resolution, public comments varied. One commenter argued for local solutions like metal detectors, while an 18-year-old suggested raising the legal age for gun sales to 21 and mandating a 10-day waiting period. A high school senior urged the council to support background checks that include school disciplinary records, and another called for a ban on "weapons of war." In response, Mayor Manheimer stated, "I am participating tomorrow in a meeting with the superintendent and the police chief and we will be discussing this topic... it is at the school board's decision about safety around schools not the City Council but we will certainly be talking about that topic and more." Council Member Mayfield also responded, noting the state preemption issues mentioned above.

Regarding the Billy Graham proclamation, public commenters criticized the council for honoring him without acknowledging his history regarding homosexuality, AIDS, and race, arguing that honoring a figure associated with "hate speech" dishonors those who were harmed. Members did not respond to these comments.

On commercial transportation, a limousine service owner, an airport shuttle owner, and a trolley company owner expressed frustration over the regulatory disparity between their heavily regulated businesses and ride-share services like Uber and Lyft. Mayor Manheimer responded, "We have significant restrictions on regulating Uber. Because they have a statutory protection where we basically can't do it." She added, "I'll have to consult with my assistant city attorney John Maddox to see exactly what those are and how those are if we've got any authority to and If you were inclined to relax those in the in light of our regulation of uber, but we'll get that information and report back to you."

Finally, a public commenter presented a "sleeping bag coat" innovation and urged the council to take action to prevent deaths from hypothermia. Council Member Gary Wilson asked if the commenter had been linked up with staff, noting, "I remember the last time that you were here you were directed to try to get in contact, link up with staff." The commenter confirmed they were already linked with the Homeless Interagency Committee (HIAC). Council Member Wilson stated, "I'm not aware that we actually lost anybody in the cold of this winter... I don't want everyone to be left with the impression that 20 people died this winter in Asheville."

Follow-ups Mayor Esther Manheimer agreed to consult with Assistant City Attorney John Maddox regarding the city's authority to regulate commercial transportation services in light of Uber/Lyft operations and stated she would report back to the council. She also stated she would participate in a meeting with the superintendent and police chief the following day to discuss school safety. Council Member Gary Wilson stated he would ask staff member Christiana for statistics on homelessness-related deaths to clarify the record. Staff member Kathy Ball stated that when the North Charlotte Street project comes before the Planning, Environment, and Development (PED) committee in March, they will have answers regarding the coordination of stormwater remediation and the Charlotte Street project.

Impact This meeting addressed critical infrastructure and public safety concerns for Asheville residents. The discussion on water and sewer regionalization highlights ongoing tensions between local autonomy and regional cooperation, with the council seeking to maintain a cooperative stance. The unanimous passage of the gun violence resolution signals the council's support for federal action on student safety, despite limited local authority. The public comment on commercial transportation underscores the competitive challenges faced by traditional taxi and limousine businesses in the ride-share era, prompting the mayor to seek legal clarification on the city's regulatory powers. Additionally, the council's engagement with homelessness data and the North Charlotte Street planning update reflects its ongoing focus on public welfare and urban development.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches