Skip to main content
  • 3 h 16 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

City Council Meeting Recap: May 9, 2017

The Asheville City Council convened on May 9, 2017, to address a range of municipal issues, including the proposed Fiscal Year 2017–18 budget, police traffic stop data, and zoning changes. The meeting began with recognitions for the Class of 2017 of the Asheville Youth Leadership Academy (KALA), who were awarded $2,000 scholarships each, and employee awards for the public safety radio system upgrade and bond referendum campaign. Mayor Esther Mannheimer proclaimed May 2017 as Public Commenter Month and May 19 as Endangered Species Day, while Council Member Gordon Smith presented a proclamation for National Public Works Week.

The Council took several formal votes during the session. The consent agenda was approved unanimously. Regarding federal funding, the Council unanimously passed motions to approve recommended Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) and HOME funding levels, move the Lee Walker Heights CDBG allocation to a reserve to allow for a second funding round later in the year, and direct staff to find a replacement funding source for the Lee Walker Heights project. The Council also unanimously approved a conditional zoning change for the Buncombe County waste transfer station at 190 Hominy Creek Road, shifting it from Institutional to Industrial Conditional with reduced landscaping requirements. Additionally, the Council unanimously voted to reappoint Alan Coxey as Chair of the Civil Service Board and appoint Whitney Lott to the Homeless Initiative Advisory Committee. A motion to waive the rule prohibiting public comment on previously addressed agenda items also passed unanimously, as did the motion to enter a closed session to consult with the city attorney regarding a lawsuit involving the Civil Service Board.

The proposed FY 2017–18 budget was presented for discussion but did not receive a vote at this meeting. The Chief Financial Officer presented a proposed total tax rate of 43.5 cents, which is 4 cents lower than the current rate, comprising a revenue-neutral rate of 39.39 cents, 3.5 cents for GO bond debt service, and 0.5 cents for transit. The total budget is $121.18 million. Staff noted risks associated with potential federal sales tax redistribution, which could result in a $1.1 million loss, and identified the cost to restructure the transit management contract at approximately $850,000. The City Manager stated, "We'll go to work on this and present a scenario. It won't make everybody happy. But we will definitely give you an option for no tax increase [beyond the bond requirement]." A public hearing on the budget is scheduled for May 23, 2017, with adoption expected on June 13, 2017.

Discussion on police traffic stop and search data was informational, with no formal vote taken. Deputy Chief Wade Wood presented findings from monthly compliance audits initiated in July 2016 and noted that APD is directing officers to issue warnings rather than tickets for minor regulatory violations when feasible. He emphasized the use of body-worn cameras to document consent, stating, "Racial bias in law enforcement, as in any other profession, cannot be completely eliminated. However, professional police management in practice aims for this goal." Council members raised concerns about discrepancies between APD reported stops and State Bureau of Investigation (SBI) records for February and August of the previous year. One Council Member remarked, "I would love for this community to get around the table in trying to solve this problem instead of where it feels to me like we are right now, which is on opposite sides of the table. And I think regular, frequent reporting and public reporting of that data will help us see where we are and where we need to go."

Public comment was received on multiple agenda items. Regarding the budget, a municipal budgeting consultant expressed concern over the proposed tax increase and the lack of a five-year operating budget projection, while a resident asked about the maintenance of a separate debt service fund as required by state law. On police data, a representative from the NAACP Criminal Justice Committee requested a commitment to identify common data points and hold workshops to set benchmarks for reducing racial disparities. An open data advocate requested that APD release its internal audit methodology and reports to the public. A representative from the Southern Coalition for Social Justice disputed APD’s claims of 100% reporting compliance, and a community organizer criticized the city for outsourcing equity work to consultants, stating, "The African American community... has lost trust and faith in the very institutions that exist solely to serve, protect, and advocate on their behalf. You're not losing the trust, you've lost the trust. It's gone." A resident of Oakley supported mandating written consent for searches, and a former police officer expressed frustration with staffing and training issues. In response to the debt service fund question, a Council Member stated that a debt service fund was established in 2012 and that the city manager and attorney would provide information to the resident.

Staff agreed to several follow-up actions during the meeting. The City Manager and staff agreed to work on an alternative budget scenario that does not raise taxes beyond the bond requirement and to present this option at the May 23 meeting. Staff also agreed to provide an analysis of dedicating the current general fund subsidy to transit to the Council. Regarding police data, the Council requested that APD provide written quarterly or semi-annual updates on traffic stop audits, and staff agreed to investigate discrepancies between APD reported traffic stops and SBI records. Staff agreed to improve the mapping of community garden sites on the city website and to work with Buncombe County to determine the safest location for the sidewalk crossing at the waste transfer station site. Finally, staff agreed to find a replacement funding source for the Lee Walker Heights project as directed by the council.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches