Skip to main content

City Council Meeting - April 25, 2017

April 25, 2017 at 11:00 AM

  • 2 h 1 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

City Council Meeting Recap: April 25, 2017

The Asheville City Council convened on April 25, 2017, to address a variety of municipal matters, including zoning amendments, public safety data, and legislative responses to state bills. The meeting began with the withdrawal of an unfinished business item regarding the expansion of the definition of homestays. Additionally, the council voted unanimously to continue a public hearing on the Buncombe County CZ transfer station request to May 9. The council also approved a consent agenda, which included a resolution supporting the raising of the age of juvenile jurisdiction from 16 to 18 in North Carolina for misdemeanors and non-violent felonies.

The council approved several proclamations recognizing specific awareness months and days. Mayor Esther E. Manheimer proclaimed April 2017 as Parkinson’s Disease Awareness Month, noting that a presenter urged citizens to contact their members of Congress regarding proposed federal cuts to medical research funding. The council also proclaimed April as Metastatic Breast Cancer Awareness Month, May 4 as National Day of Prayer, April as Stand Against Racism Month, May as Building Safety Month, and May 7–13 as National Drinking Water Week.

A significant portion of the meeting was dedicated to a presentation by Ian Mance of the Southern Coalition for Social Justice regarding racial demographics in traffic stops and searches. Mance presented data indicating that Black drivers are stopped and searched at significantly higher rates than White drivers, despite similar rates of contraband discovery. He highlighted a data reporting gap, stating, "Of the 50 traffic citations that we pulled... we discovered that 58% of them were not in the state database." Mance proposed four policy recommendations, including scrutinizing data reporting, de-emphasizing equipment-based stops, instituting mandatory written consent to search, and conducting routine audits of individual officer stop data. Councilmember Keith Young responded to the data, stating, "Driving while black in Asheville is real... I want to know more about it as far as how we're going to be able to address the issue."

The council held public hearings on two zoning items and approved both by unanimous vote. The first was an amendment to the Lee Walker Heights Urban Place conditional zoning request, increasing the unit count from 199 to 212 and adding a new entrance via a 50-foot easement across Duke Energy property. The second was a wording amendment to the Unified Development Ordinance (UDO) regarding cottage developments, which eliminates the 1,000-foot separation requirement (reducing it to 200 feet), eliminates the 15% finished grade requirement, raises the maximum unit count to 15, and removes design standards for single-family structures.

Regarding the pending state bill (SB 285) that would mandate Asheville to divide into six council districts, City Attorney Robin Kern explained that the council must initiate a charter amendment process to allow voters to choose between the current at-large system and the proposed six-district system. Mayor Manheimer stated, "I personally have always wanted to move toward a road [road] referendum... The question is, what is it that you put on the ballot for the voters to choose from?" The council agreed to initiate the statutory process to place the six-district proposal on the ballot, with the first required meeting to consider the resolution of intent scheduled for June 13.

Public comments were received on several topics. Regarding the traffic stop data, a public commenter expressed disappointment in the city’s response, arguing that the city should not "throw money at an existing problem" while the police department requests additional funding. Another public commenter expressed frustration that the issue is being "kicked down the road" to another committee, urging the council to implement the proposed reforms quickly. Mayor Manheimer responded by explaining the council-manager form of government, stating, "We're not structurally set up to impose policy decisions directly onto the police chief... We're just trying to figure out how to do that [make real change as quickly as possible]." On the districting bill, a public commenter argued that the proposed six-district bill is a "unique threat" to the city’s ability to tackle holistic challenges, urging the council to find a "best choice" alternative for the ballot. Councilmember Keith Young responded to a comment about power inequity by explaining that the council-manager system is designed so that the council makes rules and staff implements them.

Several follow-ups were established during the meeting. The council agreed to have the police chief review the information and recommendations presented by Ian Mance, with the department’s response directed to return to the full council. The timeline aims for the May 9 meeting if possible; otherwise, it will be presented at the first full council meeting in June (June 13), potentially with an interim stop at the Public Safety Committee on May 22. Additionally, the council agreed to schedule a presentation on the Food Action Plan for the May 9 meeting, with the City Manager agreeing to invite Amber Weaver to discuss the implemented pieces of the plan. The Chair also agreed to receive and distribute any written information provided by a public commenter regarding the waste management zoning issue prior to the May 9 hearing.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches