City Council Meeting - April 11, 2017
April 11, 2017 at 11:00 AM
- 2 h 2 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
City Council Meeting Recap: April 11, 2017
The Asheville City Council held its regular meeting on April 11, 2017, focusing primarily on routine administrative approvals, the ongoing debate over electoral district structures, and significant public concern regarding the city’s budget and social services. The agenda included the approval of a consent agenda, a review of polling data on redistricting, and an extensive public comment period addressing the Strategic Partnership Fund (SPF) and the proposed increase to the Asheville Police Department (APD) budget. The meeting concluded with the Council entering a closed session to discuss confidential matters and industrial expansion.
Key Decisions The Council approved the consent agenda by voice vote, with all members in favor and none opposed. This approval covered routine items, including a pass-through appropriation for a railroad quiet zone study, the sale of a dump truck, and a grant from the Tourism Promotion and Development Fund. No formal vote was taken to establish a redistricting commission; however, the Chair indicated a consensus to direct staff to return to the next meeting with a timeline and options for creating an independent commission to draw district lines, which would subsequently lead to a ballot question. The Council also voted unanimously by voice vote to enter a closed session to discuss privileged and confidential information and matters relating to the location or expansion of industries, adjourning the first session immediately after.
Discussion Highlights A central topic of discussion was the shift from at-large elections to single-member districts. Tyge Watts, a pollster, presented telephone survey results, clarifying that the data represented a "snapshot in time." Watts noted that while many initially preferred the status quo, a significant portion voted "yes" for single-member districts once specific ballot language was presented, stating, "It means that people are all over the place... It’s not surprising that something like this could change... once people got into the details of it, they realized, maybe I don’t like that. Maybe I’ll stay with what I have." A council member responded to the poll results by stating, "My takeaway from this is we need to get something on the ballot."
The Council also addressed the financial pressures on local government. The Mayor emphasized that state and federal cuts are forcing funding burdens onto local government, stating, "I do think it's important for people to understand that there is a strategy from the top down to force the cuts on nonprofits from the federal and state level to push these decisions and funding burdens onto local government. That is not an accident." Another council member added, "I would go one step further than the mayor... it's very specifically the intent of the federal government... and the Raleigh government... to force as many costs onto the cities as possible... so that's the kind of thing we're fighting against here." Regarding the railroad quiet zone, Transportation Director Ken Putnam clarified that the city is not building gates, stating, "I just want to be real clear that we're not going to build gates," explaining that the developer is paying for the study and the city is only passing through the administrative fee.
Community Input Public comment was extensive, with residents expressing strong opinions on the Strategic Partnership Fund (SPF) and the police budget. Multiple commenters criticized the tone of previous budget hearings, with one noting their organization was recommended for only $6,500 out of a $50,000 request, contrasting this with city spending on consultants. Another commenter urged council members to visit nonprofits to understand their work, calling for the city to take responsibility for the state of Black Asheville. A program director argued that the total SPF amount is insufficient to meet the city’s 2036 vision goals, while another raised equity concerns about a "non-profit industrial complex." In response, the council member in question apologized for her tone, stating her intention was good but she failed to seek understanding first, and offered to visit programs. Another member noted the difficulty of allocating limited funds, and a council member personally thanked a specific teacher, acknowledging that the burden for these programs may shift to the city.
Regarding the proposed $1 million increase to the APD budget, several commenters expressed opposition. One resident urged the city to prioritize Black lives over police funding, calling for restorative justice. Reverend Amy Cantrell presented statistics showing Asheville has a higher police-to-population ratio than the national average, arguing that adding 15 officers would make it the second-highest in the state. She stated, "More cops doesn't mean less crime," and advocated for investing in root causes of crime rather than more policing. Other commenters cited incidents of police misconduct and questioned the lack of public de-escalation training data. No council members or staff responded directly to these specific comments regarding the police budget during the recorded portion of the transcript; the Chair acknowledged the speakers and moved to the next item. Additionally, a resident questioned the logic of using an at-large vote to decide on breaking the city into districts, and another asked what happens if the state bill regarding districts passes but the local referendum votes "no."
Follow-ups Staff members Robin (City Attorney/Legal) and Gary (Staff) agreed to develop a timeline and options for establishing an independent redistricting commission to present to the Council at the next meeting. Purchasing Manager Amy Patterson noted a typo in the consent agenda ("waiter" instead of "waiver") which will be corrected. The Chair invited residents with questions or concerns to email the council.
Impact This meeting highlights the tension between local fiscal constraints and state/federal policy shifts, as well as the community's deep engagement with issues of equity and public safety. The decision to move forward with options for an independent redistricting commission signals a potential change in how city council seats are elected, which will require a future ballot question. The lack of direct response to the police budget concerns during public comment, combined with the unanimous approval of the consent agenda, suggests the Council is proceeding with its current budgetary and administrative plans despite significant public opposition to specific funding allocations.
Meeting Video & Transcript