City Council Meeting - February 14, 2017
February 14, 2017 at 11:00 AM
- 2 h 13 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
City Council Meeting Recap: February 14, 2017
The Asheville City Council convened on February 14, 2017, to address a wide-ranging agenda that included zoning amendments, budget adjustments, and public infrastructure projects. The meeting focused heavily on updates to the Unified Development Ordinance (UDO) to streamline the review process for large projects in the Central Business District (CBD) and outside of it. Additionally, the council voted on fee structures for the Aston Park Tennis Center, approved a strategic plan for homelessness, and considered improvements for Pritchard Park.
Key Decisions and Votes The council approved several items unanimously during the consent agenda and public hearings. Notably, the council approved a modified fee schedule for the Aston Park Tennis Center, phasing in increases with half the increase effective April 1 and the full increase effective July 1. The council also unanimously approved the Homeless Initiative Advisory Committee’s Five-Year Strategic Plan on Homelessness. In terms of zoning, the council unanimously approved revised wording for UDO Articles 2, 5, 7, 8, 11, 16, and 17, which modifies the Level 3 review process to use conditional zoning for large projects in the CBD. Furthermore, the council unanimously approved amendments to UDO Section 759, returning final approval for Level 2 projects outside the CBD to the Technical Review Committee with enhanced public notification.
The council also unanimously approved a budget amendment of $197,175 to support the staffing and administration of the new Capital Projects Department. Regarding Pritchard Park, the council unanimously adopted a resolution authorizing the City Manager to contract with Pinnacle Landscapes LLC for improvements totaling $194,349 plus a $38,000 contingency. However, the transcript does not record the final outcome of the subsequent hand votes taken to approve the revised plan for Pritchard Park or the related funding motion. The council unanimously appointed Russell Thatcher to the Board of Electrical Examiners but decided to delay making a recommendation for the vacancy on the Homeless Initiative Advisory Committee, allowing the committee time to review three qualified applicants.
Discussion Highlights A significant portion of the meeting was dedicated to the UDO amendments. Councilmember Smith emphasized the importance of a third-party sustainable tourism study to examine wages, traffic impacts, and the economic retention within the community. Councilmember Mayfield clarified that the council has not approved every hotel built in the city, noting that most were constructed within existing rules, and expressed concern that previous changes had shifted council responsibility to the Planning and Zoning Commission. Staff presented the Capital Projects Department budget, with Jade Dundas explaining that the new group would seek efficiencies in contracting and project implementation. Regarding Pritchard Park, staff explained that the proposed fencing was designed to be outside the tree drip line and that 40-inch height aligns with urban park best practices. One council member expressed a preference for a deck over fencing to protect the tree, suggesting the plans should be reconsidered to avoid cutting back on established public use.
Community Input Public comment was extensive, covering topics from local fees to national politics. Regarding the Aston Park fees, a public commenter argued that the proposed phased increase represented a 66% hike that could cause membership loss. Councilmember Smith responded by stating that the previous year’s lack of increase was a mistake and that rates were set to market value three years ago. On the UDO changes, a public commenter representing the Downtown Commission requested clarity on "McKibben standards" such as living wages; Councilmember Smith replied that the city cannot legally dictate wages beyond state law but can use "moral suasion." Another public commenter, a retired resident, opposed the rules on property rights grounds, while a representative of the Western North Carolina Green Party raised concerns about gentrification and the hotel boom. No specific members responded to these latter comments.
Comments on Pritchard Park were largely supportive, with one public commenter noting the design saves a large tree and adds green space. Another suggested using the 1% art budget for murals, and a third suggested adding a whiteboard for graffiti to reduce vandalism. During general public comment, a resident spoke at length about national political divisions, prompting a brief response from the Chair. Another public commenter raised questions about Asheville City Schools, including charter schools and the achievement gap; a council member responded by expressing confidence in the school district’s record. Finally, a public commenter supported the Chief of Police’s request for an additional $1 million in operating expenses, suggesting the funds be used to hire public health professionals to address homelessness and mental health, to which members did not respond.
Follow-ups Staff agreed to run the numbers for the Aston Park fee split to confirm the exact dollar amounts for the April 1 and July 1 phases. Staff also indicated they would continue working on the concept of an earlier, voluntary presentation step for Level 3 developers, potentially reporting back in six months to a year. Additionally, staff will include bond-funded projects in the upcoming five-year capital schedule update to be presented to the council later in the spring. The Boards and Commissions Committee agreed to review the three applicants for the Homeless Initiative Advisory Committee vacancy and provide a recommendation at a future meeting. The council scheduled to interview six candidates for the three open seats on the Asheville City Board of Education on February 28, 2017. Staff also noted that a listening assistance system for the audience was intended to be operational on the day of the meeting but was not working.
Impact These decisions directly affect how large-scale development is reviewed in Asheville, particularly in the downtown area, by introducing conditional zoning for Level 3 projects and enhancing public notification for Level 2 projects outside the CBD. The approval of the Five-Year Strategic Plan on Homelessness and the budget for the new Capital Projects Department signals a shift in how the city manages long-term infrastructure and social services. The phased fee increases at Aston Park and the potential improvements to Pritchard Park will impact local residents and businesses, balancing the need for revenue and maintenance with community access and environmental preservation.
Meeting Video & Transcript