Skip to main content
  • 4 h 45 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

City Council Meeting Recap: January 24, 2017

The Asheville City Council convened on January 24, 2017, to address a range of administrative, planning, and public safety matters. The meeting opened with a proclamation designating February 12, 2017, as International Darwin Day, followed by the unanimous approval of the consent agenda. The council also unanimously approved a request to rezone six single-family lots and a portion of a private right-of-way in the Scottish Circle area from Office 2 to Residential Single-Family High Density (RS8). Additionally, the council unanimously approved the 2017 National City School Board essay questions and made two commission appointments: Ed Flowers to the Historic Resources Commission and Darren Green to the Riverfront Area Redevelopment Commission.

A significant portion of the meeting was dedicated to a quasi-judicial public hearing regarding a proposed 8-story, 185-room Embassy Suites hotel at 192 Haywood Street. The applicant, Parks Hospitality Group, presented site plans, architectural designs, and expert testimony from an appraiser, a traffic engineer, and a planning expert. Despite the presentation, the council voted unanimously to deny the conditional use site plan review. The council determined that the project failed to meet six of the seven required conditional standards (Standards 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, and 7). The City Attorney noted that the applicant bears the burden of proving each standard, and a council member recommended denial because the project did not meet the requisite criteria.

The council reviewed two major staff presentations. Chief Hooper provided an update on the Asheville Police Department, highlighting 2016 crime trends, recruitment, and community policing initiatives. He noted that downtown recorded more part one crime in 2016 than the other four top locations combined, attributing this to the disparity between the department’s staffing for a population of 87,000 and the potential daily visitor count of up to 160,000. Planning Director Todd Oclocheany presented a progress report on the Comprehensive Plan update, emphasizing that housing values increased at a much faster rate between 2012 and 2016 compared to peer cities, which underscores the lack of affordable housing.

Public comment was received on several items. Regarding the Scottish Circle rezoning, a representative of the applicants requested approval to protect a tree buffer, alleging a nearby developer was attempting to bypass requirements; a council member noted the Tree Commission is working to convince developers to analyze existing tree cover before design. For the hotel project, public commenters expressed both support and opposition. Supporters cited the need to revitalize the western corridor, resolve stormwater flooding for the adjacent church, and provide meeting space, while opponents raised safety concerns regarding visibility at the North French Broad and Haywood Street intersection and noted that the project should be considered one development under the Enterprise Development Ordinance. Staff clarified that the council was reviewing the specific project against the seven standards, and a traffic engineer estimated peak hour trips at 14 in the morning and 18 in the evening.

During open public comment, a spokesperson for Asheville City Watch reported being illegally towed due to a missing recovery number on a sign and alleged non-compliance with Ordinance 1118, which requires tow companies to notify police within 30 minutes. A representative of the WNC Advocacy League criticized the city’s lack of an "open-door policy" and proposed that police be notified before towing. The Mayor stated the issue would be examined by the Public Safety Committee, and another member noted the state legislature had stepped in since 2008. Separately, a resident representing homeless individuals protested a proposed fence at Preacher Park, arguing it would create a "choke zone" for pedestrians. A council member responded that feedback from the Homelessness Initiative Advisory Committee indicated that compacted undergrowth was caused by all park users, not just homeless individuals, and stated that the council would work to resolve the issue.

Staff agreed to several follow-up actions. For the Police Department, staff agreed to send the Chief’s presentation materials to council members, revisit the request for additional downtown police officers during budget work sessions, provide detailed accident data for specific traffic hotspots including the bridge, and begin de-escalation training for all officers in February with completion targeted by spring. Staff also announced upcoming meetings with the Housing Authority and school principals in the Irwin district to discuss crime reduction partnerships. Regarding the Comprehensive Plan, staff agreed to clarify the definition of "vacant homes" regarding seasonal residences, double-check the definition of "household income," correct terminology from "captive/choice riders" to "transit-dependent/elective riders," investigate the impact of annexation restraint on sprawl, and review a potential error in a graph on page 115 regarding workforce versus subsidized housing percentages. Staff also agreed to provide a report to the Public Safety Committee regarding the enforcement of the towing ordinance by the next meeting on February 27.

The denial of the hotel permit and the ongoing work on the Comprehensive Plan have significant implications for the city’s development trajectory and housing affordability. The police department updates highlight the challenges of policing a high-visitor downtown area, while the public comments on towing and park management reflect community concerns regarding public safety and the treatment of vulnerable populations. The council’s commitment to reviewing specific data and definitions ensures that future planning and policy decisions are grounded in accurate information and community feedback.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches