City Council Meeting - October 25, 2016
October 25, 2016 at 11:00 AM
- 1 h 47 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
City Council Meeting Recap: October 25, 2016
The Asheville City Council convened on October 25, 2016, to address a range of routine and special business items, including transit policy, urban planning, and public space management. The meeting began with a proclamation designating October 28th as Hispanic Restaurant Tour Day. The Council then reviewed the consent agenda, approving routine items except for one specific resolution, which was pulled for separate discussion.
Key Decisions The Council voted on five major items during the session. The consent agenda, excluding the fare-free transit resolution, passed unanimously. The Council then approved a resolution to authorize a fare-free day on the city’s transit system for November 8th, Election Day; this resolution also passed unanimously. In a public hearing, the Council approved a land use incentive grant for a 70-unit affordable housing development on Simpson Street, with the vote being unanimous. The Council also approved a wording amendment to the signage ordinance, which removes the signage plan application process from the Unified Development Ordinance (UDO) and directs variance requests to the Board of Adjustment; this amendment passed with one member voting opposed. Finally, the Council unanimously approved an ordinance amendment creating two "high-impact areas" for street performances to manage pedestrian safety and traffic flow in the downtown.
Discussion Highlights A significant portion of the meeting was dedicated to the Haywood Street planning process, where the advisory task force presented updates on the visioning process and a list of potential temporary uses. The Mayor expressed concern that if the list contained too many items, it would reflect individual preferences rather than consensus, prompting the task force to agree to narrow the list to a prioritized short list. The Council also discussed communication strategies regarding a recent tree removal incident at the George Washington Carver Edible Park. A council member emphasized the need for a core commitment to ensuring the right people are at the table when decisions are made, noting that the issue is not difficult to resolve. On the topic of street performances, a council member remarked that Asheville is in a unique position regarding busking culture and thanked staff for "inventing a new wheel" to balance art, safety, and commerce.
Community Input Public comment was received on several agenda items. Regarding fare-free transit, a public commenter who is a member of the Transit Committee suggested that making every voting day fare-free would be easier to market. In response, a council member stated that they would love to explore making this permanent to avoid it becoming a recurring election cycle issue, and another member suggested it could be part of a future proposal regarding fees and charges.
During the discussion on the Edible Park, multiple public commenters addressed the communication breakdown. One commenter, representing the Asheville-Buncombe County Food Policy Council, described the incident as a "communications incident" and requested the city move toward collaboration and empowerment. Another commenter, the Executive Director of Bountiful Cities, noted that the incident created conflict and that volunteers feel dismissed, emphasizing the need for accountability. A third commenter from the Urban Agriculture Alliance stated the issue could have been prevented with a simple email, while a fourth commenter from Just Economics argued that marginalized people in the community do not feel listened to. The transcript summary does not record a specific member responding directly to these comments; however, a council member did quote George Washington Carver and expressed hope that the incident would accelerate the implementation of the Food Action Plan.
For the street performance ordinance, a public commenter representing the Asheville Buskers Collective expressed support for the plan, thanking staff for maintaining Asheville’s unique busking culture. A council member responded by stating that having leaders from the arts and culture community help get the ordinance right is "really gratifying." Finally, during general public comment, a resident of the East End expressed frustration with staff accessibility, describing staff as a "dark and impenetrable place." No specific member replied directly to this comment before the chair moved to adjourn.
Follow-ups The Haywood Street task force agreed to narrow their list of temporary uses to a manageable number, such as two or three options, and bring a recommendation back to the Council. The task force noted they do not have a meeting scheduled before November 8th and will work with staff to determine a return date. Staff stated that a meeting regarding the Edible Park lighting plan and its impact on trees is scheduled within the next month. Additionally, staff indicated that if the Council takes action on the street performance ordinance—which it did—they will be ready to implement the markings and educational materials within two weeks. A council member also noted that a tree canopy study, for which the city would contribute $5,000, is already before the Planning and a public commenter committee, and staff will bring it back to the Council, likely in early next year.
Impact These decisions directly affect how residents interact with city services and public spaces. The fare-free transit day aims to facilitate voting access on November 8th, while the street performance ordinance establishes clear zones for busking to balance artistic expression with pedestrian safety. The approval of the affordable housing grant on Simpson Street supports the development of 70 new affordable units. Furthermore, the Council’s engagement with community partners regarding the Edible Park and the Haywood Street visioning process signals an ongoing effort to refine communication strategies and urban planning approaches in response to community feedback.
Meeting Video & Transcript