City Council Meeting - September 27, 2016
September 27, 2016 at 11:00 AM
- 1 h 58 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
City Council Meeting Recap: September 27, 2016
The Asheville City Council convened on September 27, 2016, to address a variety of municipal matters, including routine administrative approvals, public hearings on zoning and aviation, and strategic discussions regarding downtown development. The meeting opened with two proclamations: one recognizing Aviation Careers Appreciation Day, highlighting the Aviation program at AB Tech which began in August 2015 and currently serves over 60 students, and another designating October 10, 2016, as Indigenous Peoples’ Day. Following these recognitions, the council approved a resolution supporting the Standing Rock Sioux Tribe’s opposition to the Dakota Access Pipeline, calling for the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers to obtain free, prior, and informed consent before proceeding.
On the consent agenda, the council approved routine items, including a professional engineering services agreement for a $30 million water project and Duke Energy easements. The council also received an update from the volunteer board on Asheville’s sister city relationships, which covered exchange students, cultural events such as a Mayan performance, and the development of a new relationship with a city in Scotland. Two public hearings were held: the first regarding a conditional zoning request at 25 Forsyth Street to re-establish a place of worship with modified standards, including 15-foot setbacks, reduced buffers, and 78 parking spaces; the second regarding an amendment to the airport airspace ordinance requiring FAA "no hazard" approval for structures that potentially penetrate navigable airspace before city permits are issued. Both requests were approved by the council.
A significant portion of the meeting was dedicated to downtown planning and development policies. Staff presented options for changing development review thresholds, expanding conditional zoning, creating a specific review process for hotels, and improving public outreach. The council provided guidance on four key issues: expressing consensus to lower the Level 3 review threshold to 100,000 square feet or 100 feet in height, potentially citywide; preferring Conditional Zoning over Conditional Use Permits for large projects to allow for mutual agreement with developers; expressing interest in a specific review category for hotels with a room-count threshold of 20-25 rooms to facilitate earlier dialogue; and agreeing to improve public notification processes, including earlier neighborhood meetings and better communication via website and social media. No formal vote was taken on these policy changes, as they are intended as guidance for staff to draft specific ordinance language.
The council also considered a request from Pisgah Legal Services to reduce venue fees for a poverty forum event at the Thomas Wolfe Auditorium. The original request was for a $4,000 reduction, but the motion was amended to transfer $3,500 from the General Fund to the U.S. Cellular Center Enterprise Fund after a council member offered a personal donation of $500. This motion failed to receive a majority of ayes, with several members voting no or abstaining due to concerns about setting a precedent and bypassing the standard nonprofit partnership process. Additionally, a council member provided an update on a recent all-day workshop focused on the city’s use of force and de-escalation policies, noting that Asheville is "to some great degree on the cutting edge" of such reviews and that the city has a chance to be a model for other communities. The meeting concluded with the council moving into closed session to consult with the City’s attorney regarding potential litigation.
Community input was provided during the public hearings and general comment periods. During the discussion on the Standing Rock resolution, a representative of the Eastern Band of Cherokee Indians thanked the council for their leadership and noted that the Eastern Band had sent $50,000 in support to the Standing Rock camp. Another public commenter shared their experience at Standing Rock, urging the council to consider the fossil fuel industry’s impact on climate change and water sources. Regarding the 25 Forsyth Street zoning request, the applicant’s representative stated that the property serves various community groups and that the church maintains a good relationship with neighbors. During general public comment, a member of the Multimodal Transportation Commission reminded residents that the Open City Hall survey for bus route changes ends on September 30, urging participation. A council member responded by noting that similar volunteer efforts had been conducted at the transit center in the past. Other public commenters discussed the lack of infrastructure for re-entering citizens to curb recidivism and expressed general gratitude for the council’s efforts.
Staff from Planning and Urban Design explicitly agreed to work up specific ordinance language and recommendations based on the council’s guidance regarding downtown development thresholds, conditional zoning, hotel reviews, and public outreach. The council also noted that the Open City Hall survey for transit changes closes on September 30. While a council member suggested reviewing retail spaces over 3,000 square feet in the downtown district to help preserve local independent businesses, the Mayor indicated this might be handled on a separate track after further research and public input, as it was a new topic. No explicit agreement was recorded from staff or other members to initiate a system tourism study with Buncombe County and the Tourism Development Authority, though it was noted as a desired conversation.
Meeting Video & Transcript