Skip to main content
  • 2 h 32 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

City Council Meeting Recap: July 26, 2016

The Asheville City Council convened on July 26, 2016, to address a wide-ranging agenda that included routine administrative approvals, updates on city programs, public hearings on development projects, and the adoption of a major bond resolution. The meeting also included a closed session to consult with the City’s attorney regarding ongoing litigation.

Key Decisions and Votes The Council approved the consent agenda, which included routine items and specific discussion regarding the implementation and funding of the body camera program. In a significant development decision, the Council voted to approve a land use incentive grant agreement for the Smith Mill Place project, a 72-unit affordable housing development. Regarding the Ingalls Markets signage plan, which exceeded current ordinance limits, the Council voted unanimously to continue the item to a future date of September 6, 2016, rather than approving or denying it at that time.

The most substantial financial action taken was the adoption of a resolution to set a public hearing for the issuance of $74 million in general obligation bonds. This package includes $32 million for transportation, $25 million for housing, and $17 million for parks and recreation. The Council also made several appointments to advisory boards, including the African American Heritage Commission, Citizens Police Advisory Committee, Comprehensive Plan Advisory Committee, Multimodal Transportation Commission, Neighborhood Advisory Committee, Sustainability Advisory Committee, and Tree Commission. Finally, the Council voted unanimously to enter a closed session to consult with the City’s attorney regarding the City of Asheville v. Stewart lawsuit to prevent the disclosure of privileged information.

Discussion Highlights During the presentation on the bond referendum, a polling consultant reported strong community support for the proposed measures, with 67% support for transportation, 60% for parks and recreation, and 67% for housing. The consultant noted these levels were among the strongest baseline benchmarks seen for bond packages in North Carolina. In response to public concerns about the cost of the bonds, a Council member cited polling data indicating that support remained high even when residents were informed of a potential tax increase of approximately $9 per month on a $275,000 home. Another Council member highlighted the City’s AAA bond rating and low debt service per capita, noting that Asheville’s debt service is $234 per person, significantly lower than Charlotte’s figure of over $1,800 per person.

On the Ingalls Markets signage plan, applicant representatives argued that the signage is necessary for safety and visibility within the large parking lot. Council members expressed concern that Ingalls is a repeat applicant for exceptions, creating inequity with other businesses. One Council member stated, "I can't believe anybody's going to turn in at the Ingalls monument and miss the store somehow," arguing that the City should either change the sign ordinance or enforce it consistently. Regarding the Smith Mill Place grant, a Council member remarked that seeing a developer make the numbers work for workforce housing is a "really big deal" and hopes it will encourage more similar projects.

Community Input Public commenters raised several issues during the meeting. An 83-year-old resident on a pension expressed skepticism about placing the bonds on the ballot, while another resident claimed servicing the bonds would result in a 10-15% property tax increase. In response, Council members cited the polling data and the City’s low debt service metrics as noted above.

During the general public comment period, a resident from the South French Broad neighborhood requested a delay to the August 9 public hearing for a new substation ordinance, arguing it lacked sufficient review time. The Mayor responded that they are "hearing you" and will determine if a delay or compromise is needed after a meeting with Duke representatives the following week. Another resident expressed concern over House Bill 972, which makes it illegal for citizens to view police footage. A Council member stated in closing remarks that they personally do not like the law, noting the irony of the state legislature restricting public access after the public safety committee worked on body camera policies. Other commenters raised concerns regarding handicap parking volunteer support, racial justice, and community policing, but no direct responses were given to these specific comments during the period.

Follow-ups Staff agreed to follow up with the Council on the timetable for the body camera grant decision, expected around October. Regarding the homestay permitting program, staff stated they are advertising for 1.5 full-time positions and will meet with third-party vendors the following week to discuss enforcement options. Staff also agreed to create a webpage providing detailed information on the financial impact of the bonds, including the maximum potential tax increase. The Mayor agreed to meet with Duke representatives the following week to determine if the substation ordinance consideration needs to be delayed or if a compromise can be reached. Additionally, the Mayor agreed to have the Assistant City Manager receive a written proposal for a tree preservation campaign to be considered by the Planning, Environment, and Development subcommittee.

Impact These decisions set the stage for significant infrastructure and housing developments in Asheville. The adoption of the $74 million bond resolution will require a public hearing and subsequent voter approval, potentially impacting property taxes and funding for transportation, housing, and parks. The approval of the Smith Mill Place grant supports the development of affordable housing, while the deferral of the Ingalls Markets signage plan allows for further review of ordinance consistency. The City’s commitment to engaging with the Racial Justice Coalition and addressing police transparency issues, as highlighted by the Chief of Police and the Mayor, signals an ongoing effort to improve community relations and internal processes.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches