Skip to main content

City Council Meeting - August 9, 2016

August 9, 2016 at 11:00 AM

  • 40 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

Key Decisions

The Asheville City Council approved a $75 million bond package for a November referendum, with all votes recorded as unanimous. The council adopted three separate bond orders without change or amendment: a $32 million transportation bond, a $25 million housing bond, and a $17 million parks and recreation bond. Following the adoption of these orders, the council unanimously passed a resolution to place these three questions on the November ballot and directed the City Clerk to publish notice of adoption and notify the Buncombe County Board of Elections. Additionally, the council unanimously approved the consent agenda and voted to appoint Bridget Herring to the Sustainability Advisory Committee on Energy and the Environment. The council also unanimously voted to continue the public hearing on an amendment to Chapter 7 of the Code of Ordinances regarding utility substations until September 6, 2016, citing a request for more community conversation. Finally, the council unanimously moved to enter a closed session to consult with an attorney regarding a lawsuit involving the State of North Carolina and the City of Asheville.

Discussion Highlights

During the public hearing on the transportation bonds, staff clarified that the bond funds cannot be used to renovate or move the downtown transportation center due to strict bond wording, though staff suggested using approximately $1 million from the Capital Improvement Plan (CIP) budget for renovations at a later date. In response to public concerns regarding the financial impact of the total debt burden, the Chair explained that the maximum tax implication is 4.1 cents, which equates to $110 per year for a home valued at $275,000, noting that revenue growth might prevent a tax increase. Another council member added that for a renter in a $275,000 unit, this could increase rent by $10 per month, describing it as "not a big hit to do a lot of good." The Chair also clarified that cities cannot use general obligation bonds for teachers or schools, noting that public safety is prioritized in the annual general fund budget.

Regarding the housing and parks bonds, discussions focused on affordability, racial equity, and homeownership, with specific mention of support within the African American community and projects like the Wesley Grant Center. Council members emphasized that the bond questions allow the people of Asheville to decide whether to accelerate toward aspirations they have communicated to the council. One council member stated, "What these bond questions allow is for the people of Asheville to decide whether to accelerate towards those aspirations that they’ve communicated to us. And if they choose to do so, we’ll be right there with them." Another member noted that the purpose of presenting the bonds to the public is to allow for debate until the vote, stating, "so what we’re doing as a council is handing it to the citizens of the city and and asking you to make a decision about our future."

Community Input

During the public hearing on the transportation bond, a public commenter spoke in opposition, arguing that the hearing was "window dressing" because the council had already determined the outcome. They contended that the $110 million total debt burden would lead to property tax increases passed on to renters, creating unaffordable housing, and noted that no funds were allocated for police, fire, or schools. In response, the Chair clarified that the council had previously decided not to move forward with a public safety bond and that public safety is prioritized in the general fund budget. Another public commenter spoke in support of the transportation bond but requested that 13–20% of the funds be focused on African American communities to reflect the demographic percentage of the population; members did not respond directly to this request.

On the housing bond, a public commenter spoke in favor, encouraging the city to share data on how the bond will advance racial equity goals from the 2036 vision statement, direct funding toward deeply affordable housing (below 30% of area median income), and address the racial wealth gap in homeownership. Another public commenter also spoke in favor, echoing points about creative ways to encourage homeownership and address racial inequality. Members did not respond directly to these specific requests. No public comments were recorded for the parks and recreation bond or the special bond referendum resolution.

In the general public comment period, a public commenter announced that Asheville will hold its first Open Streets event on September 18, 2016, from 1:00 PM to 5:00 PM, explaining that the event closes streets for walkers and bikers and involves over 25 partners. Members did not respond. Another public commenter asked the council to sign a letter honoring the International Day of Natural Disaster Reduction (October 12), arguing that forests provide critical ecosystem services and that European bioenergy policies are driving demand for wood pellets, threatening local forests. Members did not respond. A public commenter spoke in opposition to the bond package, labeling it a "Ponzi bond" and arguing that the bond would lead to significant tax increases for poor people. A council member responded, stating that as a long-time independent business owner who now makes less than $29,000 per year, they consider the taxes "an amazing bargain" and are willing to continue supporting city efforts. Finally, a public commenter announced that "Hemp X Asheville" would be held at Highland Brewing Company on August 19 and 20, describing hemp as beneficial for economic development and environmental protection. Members did not respond.

Follow-ups

The council agreed to continue the public hearing on the utility substation ordinance amendment until September 6, 2016. The council agreed to notify the selected appointee, Bridget Herring, of the decision the following morning. The council directed the City Clerk to publish notice of the adoption of the bond orders and to notify the Buncombe County Board of Elections regarding the special bond referendum.

Impact

This meeting finalized the process for placing a $75 million bond package on the November ballot, which will determine whether the city can proceed with major investments in transportation, housing, and parks and recreation. The unanimous approval of the bond orders and the referendum resolution signals the council's commitment to letting residents make the final decision on these projects. The continuation of the utility substation hearing to September 6, 2016, indicates that further community conversation is required before that ordinance amendment can be finalized. The appointment of Bridget Herring to the Sustainability Advisory Committee ensures continued citizen input on energy and environmental issues.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches