City Council Meeting - November 17, 2015
November 17, 2015 at 11:00 AM
- 3 h 40 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
City Council Meeting Recap: November 17, 2015
The Asheville City Council convened on November 17, 2015, to address a range of municipal issues, including transit management, housing regulations, and personnel changes. The meeting began with the recognition of three retiring council members, followed by a review of routine administrative items and a significant public hearing regarding short-term rental regulations.
Key Decisions and Votes
The Council voted unanimously to delay the buffering ordinance until August 23, 2016. This decision was made to allow Duke Energy time to identify a new site for the Hill Street substation, as requested in a letter to the council. The Council also approved the addition of one full-time equivalent position for a Downtown Central Business District Coordinator, funded partially by the Parking Enterprise Fund and partially by general fund savings. This motion passed with all members in favor and none opposed.
Regarding the transit system, the Council voted to extend the contract with First Transit Incorporated through June 30, 2016. Staff explained that this extension is necessary to allow time for a new Request for Proposals (RFP) process to select a new management company by July 1, 2016. The vote passed with all members voting "Aye" and no members opposed.
The Council approved amendments to the Homestay Ordinance, which governs short-term rentals in primary residences. The approved changes include striking the requirement for a minimum of 2,500 square feet and replacing it with a maximum of two bedrooms available for rent; removing the requirement for off-street parking; reducing the proof of residency requirement from three forms of identification to two; and removing the restriction that prevented concurrent home occupations and homestays. The Council also added eligibility for non-conforming properties that do not meet current setback or zoning requirements. All four motions related to the homestay amendments passed with all members in favor and none opposed. Additionally, the Council voted to revisit the ordinance in 4, 8, and 12 months to review staff reports on permit numbers and complaints.
Consent Agenda and Routine Items
A motion was made to approve the consent agenda with the exception of Item J (Transit). The transcript summary indicates that all members voted "Aye" and no members opposed, resulting in the passage of the consent agenda. This agenda included an agreement with the North Carolina Department of Transportation (NCDOT) for over 12,000 feet of new sidewalk on Leicester Highway, expected to be completed by 2018, and a franchise for a low-speed vehicle shuttle service operating between downtown hotels and restaurants. Staff noted that the shuttle is a registered vehicle with a 4–6 passenger capacity and operates 365 days a year.
Retiring Council Members
The Council recognized Councilman Jan Davis, Vice Mayor Mark Hunt, and Councilman Chris Pelley, who are leaving office. Resolutions expressing gratitude for their service were adopted for each member. Jan Davis, who served since 2003, thanked City Manager Gary Jackson and staff, stating, "I think that our employees are what makes the city great." Mark Hunt, who served since 2011, acknowledged Mayor Esther Manheimer’s leadership regarding the Duke Energy substation issue. Chris Pelley, who served since 2011, was also honored. The transcript records the reading of these resolutions and the presentation of plaques, though it does not explicitly record a roll-call vote for each individual resolution.
Public Hearing: Homestay Ordinance
The Council held a continued public hearing on amendments to the Unified Development Ordinance regarding homestays. Public comment was extensive, with residents expressing both support for and opposition to the proposed rules. Several commenters argued that Accessory Dwelling Units (ADUs) should be included in the definition of homestays, noting that ADUs are owner-occupied and have minimal footprints. Others expressed concern that homestays would undermine affordable housing goals and change the character of neighborhoods, citing examples from other cities where short-term rentals caused issues. Some residents requested that the Council postpone the vote until the new council members took office following the recent election, or to pilot the rules in a single neighborhood.
In response to questions about data, staff reported that there were 30-40 active notices of violation, most of which were given extensions pending the vote. Staff clarified that most complaints were for illegal whole-house short-term rentals, not homestays, and that homestays are generally compatible because the owner is present. A council member noted that only 16-18 permits had been issued since 2005. The Chair clarified that expanding the definition to include ADUs would require a separate ordinance amendment reviewed by Planning and Zoning, which could not be done that night.
Transit Management Discussion
During the discussion of the transit contract extension, public commenters raised concerns about safety and service reliability. One commenter, identified as the local president of the Amalgated Transit Union 128, reported that a bus was shot at on November 12, 2015, and that the management company had not inquired about the well-being of passengers or employees. Another commenter, a transit employee, reported that eight buses were out of service due to mechanical issues and that drivers were working on their days off. Transportation Director Ken Putnam responded that while reports didn't always match the public's claims, staff would "look into that and make sure that the buses are on the route." A council member asked staff to "redouble efforts" to enforce the contract and insist on performance.
Follow-Ups
Staff agreed to look into reports of buses not running and ensure buses are on route. The Council committed to reviewing the homestay ordinance in 4, 8, and 12 months to assess permit numbers, complaints, and other concerns. Staff indicated interest in expanding the definition to include ADUs for future Planning and Zoning review. The Council also entered a closed session to consult with an attorney regarding a lawsuit involving Rebecca Robertson, Crystal Weatherly, and the City of Asheville, and to discuss the location and expansion of industries.
Meeting Video & Transcript