Skip to main content

City Council Meeting - November 10, 2015

November 10, 2015 at 11:00 AM

  • 3 h 10 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

City Council Meeting Recap: November 10, 2015

The City Council of Asheville convened on November 10, 2015, to address four primary agenda items: a consent agenda, a public hearing on conditional zoning, an economic development resolution, and unfinished business regarding the Eagle Market Street development. The meeting focused heavily on community planning conflicts and the financial restructuring of a stalled downtown project.

Key Decisions The Council voted on three of the four agenda items. The motion to approve the consent agenda, which included a resolution naming Fire Station 8 in memory of Firefighter Jimmy Edward Trent, passed with no recorded opposition. Regarding the request for conditional zoning at 852 Hendersonville Road for a self-storage facility, the Council voted to deny the request, finding it inconsistent with the comprehensive plan and the Shiloh Community Plan. A motion was made to adopt a resolution authorizing the City Manager to sign a Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) with the Economic Development Coalition (EDC) for the 2015-16 budget year; this motion passed, though at least one opposition was noted. For the Eagle Market Street development project, a motion was made to approve changes to the City’s funding agreements, but no vote was recorded in the transcript segment provided, as the Chair opened the floor for public comment before proceeding.

Discussion Highlights The most significant debate centered on the self-storage facility at 852 Hendersonville Road. Council members discussed the tension between the developer’s request and the Shiloh Community Plan, a document developed over nine years to limit commercial encroachment into the historic Afro-American neighborhood. One Council Member stated, "I think the Shiloh neighborhood plan does matter... But when the community has come together and created a plan, I think it's up to us to abide by it." Another member expressed concern that the project "clearly violates some of the basic tenets" of that plan.

Regarding the Eagle Market Street project, presenters explained that modifications to the City’s existing agreements were necessary to satisfy bank underwriting requirements for a new construction loan of approximately $3 million to $3.5 million. Staff clarified that the City was not being asked for new money, but rather a rearrangement of committed funds to improve cash flow. The proposed changes included converting up to 30 of the 62 deeply affordable units into "workforce" housing, accelerating the disbursement of $2.8 million in City funds to 50% of project completion, adjusting the disbursement of $218,000 in Section 108 funds and a $50,000 loan, and reducing the interest rate on the City’s Housing Trust Fund loan from 2% to 0%. The City Attorney’s Office emphasized that no additional funds were being requested.

Community Input Public comment on the self-storage facility was divided. A representative for the Shiloh Community Association argued that the 2025 plan was designed to stop commercial encroachment and stated, "to destroy Shiloh is to destroy Asheville's history." Other residents spoke in favor of the project, with one presenting a petition from 28 residents and arguing that the self-storage facility was a "low-impact transition" compared to other potential uses like a gas station. A representative from the development team expressed frustration that the project had been "derailed" after a positive pre-development meeting. No specific Council members directly replied to these individual comments during the public comment period.

For the Eagle Market Street project, a resident urged the Council to keep the 62 units deeply affordable rather than converting them to workforce housing, noting that conversion would increase cash flow for the project. Another resident emphasized the importance of the project’s success for the African American community and requested space for entrepreneurs of color. A former Council Member spoke in support, framing the approval as a necessary investment to avoid leaving the site unfinished. In response to questions about the loss of affordable units, the Executive Director of Mountain Housing Opportunities (MHO) explained that MHO did not want to ask the City for new funds, stating, "We have, as I told the newspaper the other day, we have over 600 apartments in this community and they're all deeply affordable, not workforce." He added that MHO is willing to build back affordability if funds are recovered in arbitration, but the current proposal is the only way to complete the project without new City cash. One Council Member stated, "I for one am NOT going to let the perfect be the enemy of the good," while another expressed concern that the City’s early disbursement of funds was "highly risky" compared to the County, which pays only upon completion.

Follow-ups A ceremony to honor Firefighter Jimmy Edward Trent was scheduled for Sunday at 3:00 p.m. at Fire Station 8. Regarding the EDC MOU, the EDC representative confirmed that his team would review the "Creative Vitality Suite" to assess its utility for the arts community, with a follow-up conversation planned for six months. No explicit follow-ups were agreed upon by members or staff regarding the Eagle Market Street motion, as the vote had not yet occurred in the recorded segment.

Impact These decisions reflect the Council’s balancing of long-term community planning with immediate economic development needs. The denial of the self-storage facility reinforces the Council’s commitment to the Shiloh Community Plan’s restrictions on commercial growth in that neighborhood. The potential approval of the Eagle Market Street modifications, if finalized, would allow the completion of a downtown revitalization project by altering the timing and terms of existing City funds, though it would reduce the number of deeply affordable housing units from 62 to a mix that includes workforce housing.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches