Skip to main content

City Council Meeting - May 12, 2015

May 12, 2015 at 11:00 AM

  • 3 h 24 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

Key Decisions

The City Council approved several items during the May 12, 2015 meeting, including the consent agenda and four proclamations for National Public Works Week, Motorcycle Awareness Month, Strive Not to Drive Week, and Relay for Life Day. The council also voted to continue the public hearing for the Roberts Street/Red Loft Project to May 26. In a 4-3 vote, the council approved the conditional zoning request to rezone a portion of a flag lot on Sardis Road from Industrial to RM16 (Residential Multifamily High Density) for the Greymont Village Apartments project, despite staff recommendations against approval. Additionally, the council approved economic development incentive grants for PolyLynx ($31,000 over five years) and High Wire Brewing ($25,000 over five years). No formal vote was taken on the final text for short-term rental (STR) and homestay ordinances; instead, the council directed staff to prepare proposed amendments based on their discussion.

Discussion Highlights

A significant portion of the meeting was dedicated to a facilitated discussion on short-term rentals and homestays. Council members debated whether to maintain the current ban on STRs in residential zones or allow them under specific conditions, with mixed opinions regarding neighborhood stability, enforcement costs, and the rights of property owners in commercial districts. One council member expressed concern that legalizing STRs could lead to a "significant flood of rental property owners moving across," worsening the long-term rental housing crisis. Regarding homestays, there was general agreement to remove the 2,500-square-foot minimum size requirement and the 500-foot separation requirement from other homestays, as well as to allow long-term tenants to operate homestays provided they reside on-site.

During the public hearing for Greymont Village Apartments, staff recommended against approval, citing comprehensive plan policies that reserve industrial land for industrial use and a lack of residential infrastructure. The applicant argued the site was unsuitable for industrial use due to topography and wetlands. Fire Chief Scott Burnett noted that because the project has only one access point, the code requires a higher level of sprinkler protection (NFPA 13) rather than the standard (NFPA 13R), though the applicant requested to use NFPA 13R. In the legislative update, a council member reported that the state legislature is still in session, noting that sales tax reallocation legislation appears to lack momentum for this session, which would be impactful on the city in a negative way if it passed.

Community Input

Public commenters raised several issues during the meeting. An employee of Industries for the Blind stated that living in the proposed Greymont apartments would save her and her husband $200–$240/month in transportation costs, improving their independence. A representative for the Oak Forest Property Owners Association detailed severe road deterioration and requested repaving; the Mayor suggested residents use the Asheville app to report potholes, and the City Manager’s office stated that a neighborhood coordinator would meet with the POA to schedule a field inspection. A public commenter representing parents of Isaac Dixon Elementary School requested that the council direct staff to set standards for substations and consider a moratorium due to safety concerns; no specific member replied directly to this request. A UNC Asheville senior presented research on bus system changes, noting that low-income riders were disproportionately dissatisfied with 2012 changes; a council member encouraged the commenter to share this information with the Multimodal Commission.

Follow-ups

Staff will prepare a proposed ordinance amendment for STRs and Homestays, incorporating the council’s feedback, which is anticipated to go to the Planning and Zoning Committee in July and then to the City Council for a final vote in August. Staff will also provide a concise guide to help residents understand the permitting process for homestays and STRs. A council member asked staff to look into the feasibility of a fare-free month for the transit system next year. A council member requested that the Economic Development Director work on a proposal to frame job data using median wages and specific job breakdowns in future incentive reports. Staff will schedule a field inspection of the Oak Forest neighborhood roads with the POA to assess conditions and determine repaving priority. The council will interview five selected candidates for the two vacancies on the Civil Service Board.

Impact

These decisions impact residents through changes in housing availability and neighborhood character. The approval of the Greymont Village Apartments allows for the construction of a 356-unit apartment complex (108 units in the city portion) on land previously zoned for industrial use, which may affect local traffic and infrastructure. The upcoming changes to STR and homestay ordinances will determine how easily residents can rent out their homes or rooms, potentially affecting housing affordability and neighborhood stability. The economic development grants support local business expansions, creating 12 jobs at PolyLynx and 15 jobs at High Wire Brewing. The field inspection of Oak Forest roads will help determine the neighborhood's priority in the city's repaving queue, addressing concerns about road conditions and safety.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches