City Council Meeting, April 28, 2015
April 28, 2015 at 11:00 AM
- 3 h 18 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
City Council Meeting Recap: April 28, 2015
The Asheville City Council convened on April 28, 2015, to address a range of legislative, planning, and public safety issues. The meeting began with a proclamation for National Drinking Water Week, honoring the upcoming retirement of Water Department Director Steve Schoaf. The Council adopted the Consent Agenda, which included economic development incentives for PolyLynx Inc. and High Wire Brewing, as well as the rescission of the downtown fare-free zone. In his legislative update, the Mayor noted that Buncombe County is disproportionately vulnerable to sales tax redistribution legislation currently in Raleigh due to the county’s reliance on a tourism economy.
The Council approved several planning and infrastructure items. The 2015–2019 Consolidated Plan and the 2015–2016 Consolidated Action Plan for Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) and Home Investment Partnership Act (HOME) funds were both passed unanimously. Additionally, the Council unanimously approved a permanent closure of a portion of Bradley Street in West Asheville and an amendment to the signage plan for the Asheville Outlets at 800 Brevard Road to accommodate the retail center's expansion. One council member voted in opposition to the signage amendment, arguing that signage laws should apply equally to all businesses. The Council also unanimously passed a motion to authorize the Mayor to sign a letter to the Western North Carolina Regional Air Quality Board requesting stricter limits on sulfur dioxide emissions from the Asheville coal plant, and unanimously approved an amendment to Resolution 6-55 regarding the defense and settlement of claims against city employees.
A significant portion of the meeting was dedicated to the Bowcatcher Flats Conditional Use Permit, a 97-unit apartment building at 128 Florence Street and White Fawn Lane developed in partnership with the Helpmate Center. The permit passed unanimously, with the official written decision scheduled for final approval in two weeks. Helpmate representatives stated they did not oppose the development but raised safety concerns for the approximately 2,100 victims of domestic violence they serve annually, requesting sidewalks and no-parking zones to prevent batterers from staking out victims. A neighboring resident requested traffic engineering measures to prevent apartment residents from using the northern entrance, which would divert traffic through the residential neighborhood. In response, the developer, who incorporated Helpmate in 1978, committed to a $10,000 contribution for security upgrades, landscaping consultation, and a discounted rental unit for a law enforcement officer. The City Traffic Engineer noted that a formal traffic study was not required because the additional traffic was minimal, but indicated that the northern entrance could be restricted to right-turn-only exits if desired. Council members also debated rent levels, with one member noting that the conditional use permit process does not allow conditioning approval on affordable housing requirements.
The Council held a public comment period regarding Duke Energy’s plan to build a power substation on property adjacent to the new Isaac Dixon Elementary School. Numerous public commenters, including parents, PTO leaders, and physicians, expressed strong opposition, citing health risks from electromagnetic fields (EMFs) and the negative impact on the school’s reputation. Commenters requested the council use its influence to pressure Duke to find an alternative site or issue a letter stating the location is inappropriate. The Mayor explained that the city lacks the authority to zone the substation out or force a site change, as the property was purchased from private landowners and no alternative city land is available. He mentioned meeting with Duke Energy’s CEO, Lynn Good, to address concerns. A council member suggested that publicity is the community’s biggest weapon, citing Duke Energy’s poor environmental image due to coal ash issues, while another suggested parents reach out to the North Carolina Utilities Commission.
Regarding appointments, the Council voted to appoint Adrian Vassallo and Kendra Penland to the Hub Economic Development Alliance Board, with each receiving five votes. The meeting concluded with the Council voting unanimously to enter a closed session to discuss the negotiation of a contract for the acquisition of real property.
Follow-ups
- A council member committed to ensuring the Transportation Department, in conjunction with the Transit Committee and Multimodal Commission, reviews all transit fares in totality and brings a report or recommendation to the Council in the coming year.
- The developer agreed to construct a sidewalk segment on Florence Street, contingent on grade, to connect the project to the existing crosswalk infrastructure.
- The developer and Helpmate representatives discussed formalizing their agreements regarding security funding and landscaping consultation. Staff noted that for the City to enforce these, they would need to be written as conditions of the permit, and the developer stated they were willing to sign a written agreement.
Impact These decisions impact residents through the implementation of new housing and infrastructure projects, the management of public funds for community development, and the regulation of local business and environmental standards. The approval of the Bowcatcher Flats permit adds housing stock to West Asheville while addressing specific safety and traffic concerns for a nearby domestic violence shelter. The public comment period on the Isaac Dixon substation highlights ongoing community concerns regarding environmental health and the placement of industrial infrastructure near schools. The letter to the Air Quality Board reflects the Council’s intent to advocate for stricter emission controls at the local coal plant.
Meeting Video & Transcript