Skip to main content

City Council Meeting, March 24, 2015

March 24, 2015 at 11:00 AM

  • 2 h 25 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

City Council Meeting Recap: March 24, 2015

The Asheville City Council held its regular meeting on March 24, 2015, addressing a wide range of administrative, development, and public safety issues. The agenda included the adoption of routine items, a continuation of a public hearing, presentations on development processes and police organizational culture, and votes on zoning and signage amendments. The meeting also featured the appointment of two new members to the Asheville City Schools Board of Education.

Key Decisions and Votes The Council voted to adopt the consent agenda, with one item (the Strategic Operating Plan) pulled for separate discussion. A motion was made to adopt the consent agenda minus that item; it was seconded, and all those in favor voted aye with none opposed, so the motion passed. Separately, the Council voted to adopt the Strategic Operating Plan as amended, changing the language regarding city-owned land for affordable housing from "Analyze" to "Identify and Initiate." This motion was seconded, passed with all ayes and no opposition. The Council also voted to continue a public hearing item until August 25, 2015, which passed unanimously.

Regarding the Unified Development Ordinance (UDO) signage amendment, which sought to increase allowances for real estate and construction signage on screening materials, the motion failed with a tally of 2 in favor and 5 not in favor. Consequently, the amendment was denied, and the suspension of enforcement actions for non-compliant signage ceased. In contrast, the Council voted to approve the conditional zoning request to rezone 1 Sunset Parkway from single-family to multifamily low-density, allowing the conversion of a historic church into two residences; this motion passed unanimously.

For the French Broad Whitewater Park, no formal motion or vote was recorded. The Chair asked for a "nod" or indication of support for the first step, which involves the City evaluating the project for integration into the River Arts District redevelopment. The Council indicated general support for this evaluation.

School Board Appointments The Council voted to appoint two new members to the Asheville City Schools Board of Education from a list of six finalists. In the first round, Shonda Sanford received 5 votes, meeting the required majority, and was appointed. Steve Dykes and Martha Geithner received 3 votes each. In the second round to select the remaining appointee, Martha Geithner received 4 votes, and Steve Dykes received 3 votes. Shonda Sanford and Martha Geithner were officially appointed to the Board.

Discussion Highlights The Council received a report from the Mayor’s Development Task Force, where the presenter noted that the City of Asheville is "certainly no more onerous than any of the others" in permitting processes, though consistency and predictability remain key concerns for developers. On the police front, a consultant from Matrix Consulting Group presented the final organizational assessment, stating that the department's issues were systemic, took years to develop, but are "solvable" with a new approach to culture. The City Manager committed to implementing a 180-day plan, including creating a Chief’s Advisory Committee and improving communication.

During the discussion on the UDO signage amendment, a council member expressed a personal inclination not to regulate the specific issue of measuring illustrated panels on temporary construction signs, finding it "a little bizarre." Another council member countered that deregulating the signage would create visual clutter and inequity, arguing that a full conversation on construction signage might not be the best use of time. Staff clarified that the existing ordinance limits such signs to 32 square feet but anticipates traditional freestanding plywood signs, and that enforcement actions are suspended while a remedy is sought.

Community Input Public comments were received on several items. Regarding the Tartan Day proclamation, a representative of a nonprofit thanked the Mayor and encouraged support for Celtic culture preservation. For the Whitewater Park, a public commenter presented a feasibility study, noting a June 2016 deadline for Phase 1 design and requesting authorization for next steps. Council members responded by discussing the need to understand ongoing operating costs to avoid taxpayer burdens similar to those seen in other park projects, while emphasizing the City’s need to remain visionary regarding recreation infrastructure.

For the 1 Sunset Parkway rezoning, a public commenter representing the neighborhood association stated that the board voted unanimously to support the request, noting the importance of voicing support for beneficial projects. Another public commenter, the project architect, highlighted the building’s historic significance and previous uses. Council members responded by expressing gratitude for the neighborhood’s support and noting the applicant’s good track record with other redevelopments.

During the general public comment period, a resident spoke regarding religious and moral issues, opposing abortion and criticizing the Council’s handling of specific events. The Chair responded only with, "Blood for blood. Thank you. Is there anyone else wishing to speak?" Another resident spoke in support of House Bill 78, asking the Council to pass a resolution backing the bill. The Chair responded, "Uh-oh, cat's out of the bag." No other members responded to this comment.

Follow-ups Staff committed to conducting an evaluation of how the Whitewater Park integrates with the River Arts District redevelopment, including physical infrastructure, operations, traffic, and financing, and to research how other cities have handled similar projects. The results of this evaluation will come back to the Council to determine if further planning or a formal agreement is needed. Regarding the police department, staff committed to implementing the 180-day plan from the Matrix Consulting report, including creating a Chief’s Advisory Committee, improving communication, and developing a performance management system. Staff will provide monthly updates to the Public Safety Committee and quarterly reports to the full Council. Additionally, staff were asked to look at the impact of a pending House bill that would exempt developers from property tax increases on developed land.

Impact These decisions impact residents through changes in local development, public safety, and education governance. The approval of the conditional zoning at 1 Sunset Parkway allows for the adaptive reuse of a historic building into residential units. The denial of the signage amendment means that enforcement actions for non-compliant construction and real estate signage will resume, with staff noting that violators have only a few days to remove non-compliant signage before fines accrue. The appointment of Shonda Sanford and Martha Geithner to the School Board will shape the direction of local public education. The ongoing evaluation of the Whitewater Park and the implementation of the police organizational plan will determine future public safety and recreation infrastructure in the city.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches