City Council Meeting, March 10, 2015
March 10, 2015 at 11:00 AM
- 31 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Key Decisions
The City Council of Asheville met on March 10, 2015, to address a variety of municipal matters, including the adoption of the consent agenda, the regulation of e-cigarettes, and the selection of candidates for School Board vacancies. The council voted unanimously to adopt the consent agenda, with the exception of two items that were pulled for separate discussion: a resolution regarding the Vance Monument and an ordinance regulating e-cigarettes. Both of these items subsequently passed with unanimous votes. The council also voted unanimously to continue two public hearings to future dates: the hearing for Graymont Village Apartments was continued to May 12, 2015, and the hearing for a nine-lot major subdivision off Shelburne Drive was continued to March 24, 2015.
In terms of appointments, the council voted unanimously to appoint Dwayne Barton and Viola Spells to two open seats on the African American Heritage Commission, and Jay Miller to one open seat on the Public Art and Cultural Commission. For the Hub Community Economic Development Alliance, where only two applicants were received for two open seats, the council agreed to extend the application period and re-advertise the positions. Finally, the council voted to select six candidates from a field of thirteen for interviews regarding School Board vacancies. The selected candidates are Joanna Best, Steve Dykes, Martha Geithner, James Lee, Shonda Sanford, and Greg Walker-Wilson. The meeting concluded with a unanimous vote to enter a closed session to consult with the city attorney regarding privileged and confidential information.
Discussion Highlights
During the discussion of the Vance Monument, a staff member noted that the credit for accomplishing the $115,000 restoration effort goes to Chris Roberts and his team. Chris Roberts, a presenter and native of Weaverville, stated that he has spent 12 years working as a tour guide at Zebulon Vance’s birthplace and wanted to do something about its degradation. The council accepted a donation of services agreement with the 26th North Carolina Regiment for the restoration.
Regarding the e-cigarette ordinance, which amends Chapter 11 of the Code of Ordinances to regulate e-cigarettes in city facilities the same as traditional lighted cigarettes, a council member expressed concern that the FDA has not yet made a determination on the safety or consistency of the products. The member stated, "until that's resolved, I wouldn't be comfortable permitting -- I mean, it seems to me the same rules ought to apply until we know something different."
For the School Board selection process, the Vice Mayor explained that to resolve confusion, each council member would indicate six candidates they would like to see interviewed. A council member remarked on the quality of the candidate field, stating, "The quality of this field of candidates... is the best it's been since I've been paying attention." Another member emphasized looking for candidates who are "collaborative," "effective leaders," and "change makers," specifically asking about "justice for the Randolph school kids" and "healthy food in our schools."
Community Input
A public commenter, identifying himself as a member of the Asheville City School Nutrition Committee, asked the council to ask the new school board candidates about their views on changing child nutrition in city schools, citing studies linking nutrition to academic achievement. In response, a council member stated, "I would second that. The quality of this field of candidates... is the best it's been since I've been paying attention."
Another public commenter, identifying himself as a chef running a program at the Reed and Eddington Centers, urged the council to prioritize candidates willing to "say yes" to change regarding healthy food access in schools. He noted that the Eddington Center has facilities to produce food locally and that there is backing from parents and students. A council member responded, "I just wanted to say that I've never been through this process, but I was really impressed by the number of the candidates and the real passion that I saw in the applications... Please stay involved with the schools. Keep your passion up and Thank you for all the effort."
Follow-ups
The City Clerk stated she would contact the selected School Board candidates the following day with consent forms for background checks. The council agreed that Human Resources staff would conduct criminal record checks, which would be reviewed at the staff level with the City Attorney; if red flags emerge, the City Attorney will be advised confidentially to factor into final decision-making. The City Clerk also stated that interviews for the six selected candidates are scheduled for March 24, 2015, at approximately 2:10 PM, and she would email the council once the time is firmed up. Additionally, staff will extend the application period and re-advertise for the two open seats on the Hub Community Economic Development Alliance.
Impact
These decisions impact residents through the regulation of e-cigarettes in city facilities, which will now be treated the same as traditional lighted cigarettes. The restoration of the Vance Monument, supported by a donation of services agreement, addresses the preservation of a local historical site. The selection of six School Board candidates for interview is a significant step in the process of filling board vacancies, with the council emphasizing the importance of leadership qualities and specific community issues such as school nutrition and equity. The continuation of the zoning and subdivision public hearings to future dates allows for further review of these development projects.
Meeting Video & Transcript