Skip to main content
PRESENTATIONS AND REPORTSBReport

Boards & Commissions Realignment Working Group

City Council Meeting (Apr 8, 2025) · April 8, 2025 at 12:00 PM

Watch this item from 28:00

Documents

What was said

We're resetting the shot clock to 15 minutes. And this is from the Boards and Commissions Realignment Working Group. And I know Elise Marder is going to make the presentation. But if you are a member of this group and you're here, you want to stand so we can recognize you, please. Okay, great. Thank you so much. All right. Thank you. Good evening. My name is Elise Marder, and I'm here on behalf of the Boards and Commissions Realignment Working Group. We are a volunteer team tasked with developing recommendations to improve the city's advisory board system. Now, specifically, our work focuses on volunteer advisory boards, not quasi-judicial boards. And throughout the presentation, I am going to use the term boards as like a shorthand for boards, commissions, committees, etc. So, of course, how do we get here? The Realignment Working Group, or RWG for short, formed in 2022 in response to a staff-led proposal to radically reduce the number of boards and to align the remaining boards with a relevant council committee. And as a working group, we conducted and reported findings from a survey of current and former board members and then presented those survey findings to the boards and commissions council committee as well as to full council. And that was last January. And since then, we conducted a survey of staff liaisons and we have prepared a report detailing our 28 recommendations. The main themes of those recommendations include goal setting, board review, communicating with counsel, technology, training, representation and participation, and board management. Our recommendations place special focus on formalization and consistency of policy. So to implement these recommendations and ensure greater consistency, we recommend centralizing operational support. Here we've just got a little timeline showing some of those milestones I mentioned, but let's jump right into the recommendations because I have very little time. So, if you recall from our previous presentation, the membership survey found that board members had a more positive experience when their board's goals were aligned with council priorities. However, the survey also revealed that goals were more often set by board members with a lot less input from council. Nearly 70% of respondents indicated that board members were involved in goal setting, but only 35% of respondents said that council members were involved in goal setting. So it's like a two-to-one ratio. So to address this, we recommend that council reviews each board's annual goals and confirms that all board goals are aligned with council priorities set during the annual council retreat. And then to require approval by council for any goals that are not directly tied to a council priority. And these reviews could also be conducted by the relevant council committee, not necessarily all of council. But implementing these recommendations will help align board goals with council work plans and will allow members to see a clearer connection between their efforts and council action. Now, the main criticism of the initial staff proposal was the drastic reduction in the number of boards from 20 to more like four or five. And it's certainly true that community needs evolve and that the city needs a system that can adapt to those changing needs. Now, currently, the annual report process is not really a strong enough tool to assess a board's effectiveness or ongoing value. But a regular review process would provide a mechanism to ensure that boards are in alignment with council goals and also to evaluate their effectiveness in pursuing their mission. So we recommend that the city establish a formal board review process. And we outline some components that could be included in the review process in our report. And we also encourage the city to include data-driven performance metrics when appropriate to do so. Now, importantly, a review does not automatically mean dissolution. There are a number of potential outcomes short of disbanding a board. But if dissolution is on the table, it should follow a formal and transparent process with opportunities for engagement from current and former members and the public. And the key here is that any review or dissolution process should be standard, transparent, comprehensive, and fair, and not a sweeping reduction by 75 or 80 percent, as originally proposed. Now in the open-ended survey responses, many members expressed a feeling that their recommendations were ignored or led to no action and this ultimately contributed to an overall sense of powerlessness or lack of impact.

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches