Skip to main content
  • 4 h 33 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

City Council Meeting Recap: September 22, 2020

The Asheville City Council held a virtual meeting on September 22, 2020, presided over by Mayor Esther Manheimer. The agenda included the adoption of the consent agenda, public hearings on zoning and street closures, appointments to various city commissions, a vote on a temporary moratorium for hotel development, and a significant amendment to the Fiscal Year 2020-21 budget focused on public safety reallocations.

Key Decisions and Votes The Council unanimously (7-0) adopted the consent agenda, which included resolutions for water system projects, fire department contracts, and grant acceptances. The Council also unanimously (7-0) voted to extend the temporary moratorium on hotel development for five months, until February 23, 2021, citing delays caused by the COVID-19 pandemic.

Regarding public hearings, the Council voted to recess both the hearing on the closure of Gayle Street (7-0) and the hearing on the Coxe Avenue Conditional Zoning Amendment (6-0) until October 13, 2020. Mayor Manheimer was recused from the Coxe Avenue item by a unanimous vote (7-0), with Vice Mayor Gwen Wisler assuming the chair for that discussion.

The Council approved a $1.1 million Housing Trust Fund loan to Juna Group Inc. for the construction of 11 affordable single-family homes by a vote of 6-1; Vice Mayor Wisler voted against the loan. The Council unanimously (7-0) appointed members to the Affordable Housing Advisory Committee, Citizens-Police Advisory Committee, Civic Center Commission, Asheville-Buncombe Historic Resources Commission, Public Art & Cultural Commission, and the WNC Air Quality Board.

The most contentious vote of the evening concerned the FY 2020-21 Budget Amendment. A motion to deny the amendment failed (2-5). Subsequently, the Council voted to adopt the budget amendment by a tally of 5-2. Councilman Brian Haynes and Councilwoman Sheneika Smith voted against the adoption.

Discussion Highlights A major portion of the meeting was dedicated to the "Reimagining Public Safety" initiative, a 30-60-90 day plan developed in response to the Black Asheville Demands coalition. City Manager Deborah Campbell presented an update, stating that while she could not support a 50% defunding of the police, the city would adjust the Asheville Police Department (APD) budget to change service delivery. APD Chief David Zak discussed policy reviews, including the elimination of the Drug Suppression Unit to focus on violent and property crime, and the implementation of new de-escalation training.

The budget amendment itself proposes reallocating approximately $770,000 from the APD budget to other departments, including Development Services, Parks, IT, and Community Engagement. This includes moving animal control, park wardens, and telecommunicator positions. Councilman Haynes proposed increasing wages for 35 firefighters to a living wage of $15/hr at a cost of $33,615; staff recommended waiting for the completion of a compensation and classification study to address pay equity holistically.

Community Input Public comment was extensive, particularly regarding the budget amendment and public safety. Commenters expressed a wide range of views: some urged the Council to vote against the budget to force more substantive action on equity and reparations, while others strongly opposed any cuts to police funding, citing safety concerns and officer morale. One commenter from South Asheville criticized the budget as a "slap in the face," arguing it did not constitute true divestment. Another commenter from West Asheville, a pastor, argued that cuts would lower morale and make the city less safe. A public commenter also raised concerns about the virtual meeting registration process, arguing that the requirement to sign up 1.5 days in advance excludes individuals with low-wage jobs or childcare responsibilities.

Follow-ups City Manager Deborah Campbell agreed to provide specific data on the percentage of participants in the public safety engagement who were directly impacted by police contact in approximately two weeks. APD Chief David Zak confirmed that the department will implement Verbal Defense Influence training in the coming year and will continue to work with local attorneys and community groups to review policies. City Attorney Brad Branham stated that the city will continue efforts with the Police Benevolent Association to develop a consensus-based legislative proposal for a citizen review board. Developer Al Clement of Juna Group committed to working with the Community Land Trust and Habitat for Humanity to identify qualified buyers for the affordable homes.

Impact These decisions mark a significant shift in how the city allocates resources for public safety, moving specific non-violent responsibilities away from the police department to other city agencies. The extension of the hotel moratorium provides additional time for the city to complete its study on hotel development impacts before new approvals can be granted. The approval of the budget amendment, despite opposition from two council members, sets the financial framework for the remainder of the fiscal year, incorporating the initial steps of the public safety reallocation plan.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches