City Council Meeting
September 8, 2020 at 12:00 PM
- 3 h 20 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
City Council Meeting Recap: September 8, 2020
The City of Asheville City Council held a regular meeting on September 8, 2020, conducted virtually. The agenda included the appointment of a new council member, approval of routine administrative items, reports on pandemic relief efforts and police conduct, and votes on hotel development regulations and tree canopy preservation ordinances.
Key Decisions and Votes
The Council voted 4-2 to appoint S. Antanette Mosley to the vacant council seat previously held by Vijay Kapoor. Councilman Brian Haynes and Councilman Keith Young voted against the appointment, while Mayor Esther Manheimer, Vice Mayor Gwen Wisler, Councilwoman Julie Mayfield, and Councilwoman Sheneika Smith voted in favor. Mayor Manheimer stated that Ms. Mosley will be sworn in before the next council meeting.
The Council unanimously approved the consent agenda, which included the minutes from the August 25, 2020 meeting. This agenda also included three items that passed with a 7-0 vote:
- A resolution authorizing the City Manager to execute a contract with CDM Smith, Inc. for an Arc Flash Hazard Analysis Study for electrical safety at water treatment plants and pumping stations.
- A budget amendment of $1,063,224 to establish a budget in the City’s Special Revenue Fund for the second round of Coronavirus Relief Fund funding received from Buncombe County.
- A resolution authorizing the City Manager to execute an amended contract with Griffin Waste Services for the rental and maintenance of portable toilets and handwashing stations for public use.
Regarding the Tree Canopy Preservation Ordinance, which had been heard in public hearing at the previous meeting, the Council passed three items unanimously (7-0):
- Initial zoning to apply the new Resource Management Overlay District to all properties within the City of Asheville corporate limits.
- An amendment to the Unified Development Ordinance establishing the Resource Management Overlay District and a new Article XIX for Tree Canopy Preservation.
- An ordinance amending the fees and charges manual for Fiscal Year 2020-21 to establish a fee-in-lieu option for tree removal.
For the hotel development moratorium, the Council held a public hearing to consider extending the temporary moratorium. While staff initially proposed a two-month extension, they recommended a five-month extension until February 23, 2021, to allow time for a Council work session and potential return to the Planning & Zoning Commission. The Council voted 7-0 to recess the public hearing, meaning the final vote on the specific duration of the extension will occur at the next meeting on September 22, 2020.
Finally, the Council unanimously (7-0) voted to fill vacancies on two boards: reappointing Sandra Kilgore and Joe Archibald and appointing Kimberly Levi to the Planning & Zoning Commission, and reappointing Andrew Celwyn to the Buncombe County Tourism Development Authority.
Discussion Highlights
City Manager Deborah Campbell reported on the 30/60/90 Day Work Plan, noting that staff initiated conversations to defund the police budget by 50% and that the City will not dispose of properties taken through Urban Renewal until a policy is adopted. She emphasized that community members expressed they were "tired of talking" and wanted action, stating, "I cannot say enough... that this is the beginning of conversations, not the end."
City Attorney Brad Branham presented Phase 1 of the internal review of the Asheville Police Department’s response to protests in May and June 2020. The report found that all tactical decisions, including the use of tear gas, were made by APD, and that no Council members provided tactical input. Councilman Brian Haynes criticized the report, stating, "To call this entire timeline... facts, I think is less than accurate. And being that we still have yet to hear from any of the witnesses that were protesters on the ground... I don’t need a report to tell me that I think we were inappropriate in many actions that we took during this." Vice Mayor Gwen Wisler added, "I don’t even necessarily disagree with you. I’m not sure that I’ve ever felt as helpless in my entire life as that week of protests and deep frustration at the... inability to... do anything."
Staff presented a draft plan to regulate hotel development, which includes an overlay map, development standards (such as a 100-foot height limit for staff-level approval), and a design review body with a scoring matrix for public benefits. Councilman Brian Haynes expressed concern that the proposal would not slow hotel development, stating, "I don't intend to support taking away council's review of hotel projects." Councilwoman Julie Mayfield noted that if she is to agree to remove Council from the approval role, "the requirements have to be really, really high and stringent for me." Mayor Manheimer suggested a work session to drill into the details.
Community Input
During the public hearing on the hotel moratorium, several residents spoke in support of extending the moratorium. One public commenter from West Asheville linked hotel development to the legacy of urban renewal and its negative impact on the Black community, urging the Council to consider a moratorium on selling land taken from Black families. Another commenter from Montford acknowledged their role in gentrification and urged a one-year extension to allow the city’s reparations process to begin. A third commenter, a veteran from Asheville, praised the Council’s previous vote on reparations and asked them to commit to the Black community by continuing the hotel moratorium until reparations plans are finalized. A fourth commenter from Asheville discussed the use of force during protests, calling for divestment from the Asheville Police Department, and argued that additional hotel development does not advance equity goals. A fifth commenter from East Asheville provided perspective on the City Attorney’s internal review, noting that it only interviewed city officials and police, and requested that the City listen to citizens’ accounts of tear gas and projectiles used against peaceful protesters.
Follow-ups
City Manager Deborah Campbell stated that staff will bring back preliminary recommendations regarding organizational and budgetary changes related to the "Reimagining Public Safety" process on September 22. She also agreed to have staff look into a constituent’s difficulty accessing the online survey. City Attorney Brad Branham stated that if the council determines anything in the police review report is inaccurate or needs updating, his office will make those edits. Staff agreed to send an email to Council members with the scoring analysis of recent hotel projects to show how they would have fared under the proposed matrix and to organize a full Council work session on the hotel development recommendations as soon as possible. Planning and Urban Design Director Todd Okolichany stated that planning staff will return to the Planning and Zoning Commission on September 23 for a potential recommendation.
Impact
These decisions impact residents through the new leadership on the Council, the implementation of tree canopy preservation rules that require developers to preserve or plant trees, and the continued pause on new hotel approvals while the City finalizes its regulatory framework. The City’s commitment to reviewing police conduct and reimagining public safety structures reflects a significant shift in how the City approaches public safety and racial equity, with staff tasked with developing concrete policy changes in the coming months.
Meeting Video & Transcript