Skip to main content

Planning and Zoning Commission – October 4, 2023

October 4, 2023 at 5:02 PM

Recap readyAdd to calendar
Previous: Sep 14 meetingNext: Oct 18 meeting
  • 2 h 7 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

Planning and Zoning Commission Meeting Recap: October 4, 2023

The City of Asheville’s Planning and Zoning Commission convened on October 4, 2023, to address administrative matters and conduct a legislative public hearing. The primary focus of the meeting was a request to conditionally rezone a nine-acre site at 2 Butler Road from Community Business (CB2) to a Residential Expansion Conditional Zone (RES-EXP-CZ). The applicant, Forno Development Group, proposed a 279-unit, four-to-five-story multifamily apartment complex on the property, which is located near Long Shoals Road, Lake Julian, and Biltmore Park.

In administrative proceedings, the commission approved the minutes from the September 14, 2023 meeting by a vote of 6-0. The body also elected new leadership for the coming term. Commissioner Kimberly Levi was elected Chair by a vote of 6-0, and Commissioner Geoffrey Barton was elected Vice Chair by a vote of 6-0. Chair Archibald stepped down from the Chair position during this segment of the meeting.

The central debate concerned the density and affordability of the proposed development at 2 Butler Road. The applicant requested a technical modification to increase density from the standard 20 units per acre to 32 units per acre. In exchange, they offered 10% affordable units, which is below the 20% standard typically required for the maximum density bonus. Craig Justice, representing the applicant, explained that the project’s financials only supported a 10% affordable unit ratio because the grant program did not work out for this specific project. Clay Mitchell, the Development Liaison, noted that designating the site as residential expansion creates an inconsistency in base density but stated that the proposal aligns with comprehensive plan goals for responsible growth and infill development.

During the public hearing, a resident expressed concern regarding the loss of tree canopy, increased traffic on Long Shoals Road, and the safety of the proposed gated secondary access. The resident also questioned the community benefit of high-end housing that local residents cannot afford. In response, Chair Levi expressed appreciation for the density in the location and argued that concentrating development reduces sprawl, while acknowledging that Long Shoals Road is a "bike nightmare." Commissioner Barton addressed the tree canopy concern by proposing a condition requiring 2% tree canopy preservation, citing a nearby project that preserved 3.5% of its existing canopy.

Following a 10-minute break, the applicant and staff agreed to several revisions to the project conditions. These included a commitment to present the voucher acceptance issue to City Council for discussion, a revision to specify a maximum of 382 parking spaces, and an explicit requirement for 40 bicycle parking spaces and 20 electric vehicle charging spaces. The applicant also agreed to work with City staff to determine the feasibility of upgrading the existing bus stop at Plot Place to a shelter. Regarding tree preservation, the applicant stated they could not commit to a specific percentage due to unknown easement constraints, so the final condition language focused on the "goal of preserving as many trees as possible."

Despite these revisions, a motion to approve the conditional zoning request failed with a split vote of 3-3. Because the motion did not receive a majority, the commission did not approve the request. Chair Levi clarified that the recommendation to City Council will reflect that the commission did not approve the zoning change, noting that it was not explicitly denied but rather recorded as not approved. Additionally, a motion to continue the Level 2 Site Plan Review for 22 Carter Street to November 1, 2023, was recorded as "missed by one," though the Chair stated the item was being continued. An item for 110 River Hills Road was withdrawn and not heard.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches