Planning and Zoning Commission – September 14, 2023
September 14, 2023 at 5:04 PM
- 1 h 34 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Meeting Overview
On September 14, 2023, the City of Asheville Planning and Zoning Commission convened to address three primary agenda items: the Reimagining PAC Square: A Vision Plan, a Level 2 Site Plan Review for a mixed-use development at 68 Carter Street, and a Zoning Map Amendment for a residential project at 115 Fairview Avenue. The commission also approved the minutes from its previous meetings on July 19 and August 2, 2023.
Key Decisions
The commission took several actions during the meeting. First, a motion to approve the minutes from the July 19 and August 2, 2023 meetings passed unanimously. Second, the commission voted unanimously to recommend that City Council adopt the Reimagining PAC Square: A Vision Plan. Third, the commission unanimously continued the Level 2 Site Plan Review for 22 Carter Street to the October 4, 2023 meeting. Fourth, the commission unanimously recommended approval of the Level 2 project at 68 Carter Street, subject to outstanding technical and design review conditions. Finally, the commission approved the conditional zoning request for 115 Fairview Avenue; all members voted in favor, with no votes against or abstentions recorded.
Discussion Highlights
Staff presented the Reimagining PAC Square: A Vision Plan, which aims to transform the area surrounding the former Vance Monument site into a more welcoming, accessible, and people-centered space. The plan includes ten design recommendations, such as improving pedestrian safety, closing North Pack Square to vehicle traffic, and creating a "Meditation Grove." Stephanie Monson Dahl, Director of Planning & Urban Design, emphasized that the space is intended for people rather than memorials, noting, "This is a space for people, and it's not a space for memorials, markers, and historic signs... It's a space to collect people." She also shared feedback from a teen focus group, stating, "We're not interested in your bronze statues. We're interested in interactive environments... It was something that sounds really simple, but it's a good wake-up call for us that we're living in a different century when it comes to placemaking in the middle of our downtown."
For the 68 Carter Street project, staff presented a ministerial review for the "Tribute Hotel Project," an eight-story mixed-use building featuring 115 hotel rooms, 24 residential units, 16,000 square feet of commercial space, and underground parking.
Regarding the 115 Fairview Avenue zoning amendment, the request involves rezoning an 8.25-acre parcel from Urban Village to Residential Expansion Conditional Zone to accommodate 269 apartment units, 12 townhomes, a swimming pool, and amenities, with a 20% affordability requirement. Derek Allen, the applicant representative, highlighted the benefits of infill development, stating, "One of the big things [about middle housing] is the infill part of that... Here we have this urban developing residential corridor... and you're starting to see houses and infill development go in... This one makes a lot of sense." Clay Mitchell, Development Liaison, recommended approval of the proposed conditional zoning with the project conditions in Exhibit E.
Community Input
During public comment on the Reimagining PAC Square plan, a public commenter suggested installing pedestrian underpasses under Biltmore Avenue and other downtown streets to alleviate traffic and improve safety, citing examples from Cincinnati, Ohio. No member or staff member responded to this specific suggestion. Another public commenter, speaking via video, urged the commission to prioritize pedestrians by integrating "testing" into the design process, suggesting temporary closures of South and North Pack Square to observe pedestrian behavior. No member or staff member responded to this suggestion. A third public commenter asked if sustainability strategies, such as reusing existing materials, could be incorporated. Stephanie Monson Dahl responded that sustainability was a major topic during the design charrette, including tree preservation and heat island effects, and stated that the next step, the master plan process, will determine specific materials and water management strategies. Another staff member added that the planning and design guide being created for the next phase can include these types of comments. A fourth public commenter noted that Asheville has a higher pedestrian accident rate than similar-sized cities and thanked the commission for addressing pedestrian concerns. A commissioner thanked the commenter for highlighting the statistics.
Regarding the 115 Fairview Avenue project, a public commenter who owns adjacent property asked if the height of the quadruplexes would be limited to 40 feet. The applicant responded that the total height is 38 feet, which is below the limit, and noted that the base level is significantly lower than neighboring homes due to topography. Another public commenter requested that the forested area behind the quadruplexes, described as a wildlife corridor for bears, be deeded to the city for perpetual protection. Clay Mitchell explained that the plan includes recorded open space, buffer areas, and tree canopy protection areas that must be preserved in perpetuity, effectively protecting the linear corridor. The applicant added that the preserved trees range from 6 to 27 inches in diameter. A third public commenter expressed strong concern about traffic congestion on Fairview Road, arguing that adding 300 more parking spaces would create a "nightmare" for vehicles and pedestrians. The applicant responded that the Traffic Impact Analysis was prepared by Davenport Engineering and received final approval from the state, which required the installation of turn lanes. The applicant argued that infill housing reduces trips to other locations and supports walkability. A commissioner commented that the commission has long wrestled with traffic impact analyses that look at individual projects rather than cumulative future growth, and expressed a preference for bike lanes over road widening. Another commissioner noted concern that the building's proximity to the road prevents future expansion, but acknowledged the applicant’s request for a reduced setback.
Follow-ups
Staff stated they are working with the Block Collaborative on a memorandum of understanding (MOU) as the first priority of the Mellon Grant, which becomes active on October 1. Staff also stated they will put out a Request for Qualifications (RFQ) for final planning and design of PAC Square. Regarding 115 Fairview Avenue, the applicant stated they would investigate who owns the adjacent bus stop. If it is in the public right-of-way, the applicant indicated they would be willing to consider upgrading the bus stop/shelter as a condition, though staff noted they could not add it as a condition until ownership was confirmed. Staff suggested that if it works out before the project goes to City Council, it could be added then. The applicant also stated they are working on the LUIGE (Low-Income Housing) program application and will have the voucher considerations and homeless priority matrix ready by the time the project goes to City Council.
Impact
The decisions made at this meeting advance significant changes to the downtown core and residential development in Asheville. The recommendation to adopt the Reimagining PAC Square plan signals a shift toward a more inclusive, pedestrian-focused public space, moving away from a memorial-centric design. The approval of the 68 Carter Street site plan facilitates the construction of a new mixed-use building in the downtown area. The approval of the conditional zoning for 115 Fairview Avenue allows for the development of a large residential project with a 20% affordability requirement, which is expected to go to City Council for final approval in October or November 2023. These actions reflect the commission's focus on balancing development with community needs, pedestrian safety, and sustainable design.
Meeting Video & Transcript