Urban Forestry Commission – June 6, 2023
June 6, 2023 at 1:00 PM
- 1 h 57 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Urban Forestry Commission Meeting Recap: June 6, 2023
The City of Asheville’s Urban Forestry Commission held a regular meeting on June 6, 2023. The agenda included personnel updates, three alternative compliance requests for tree preservation, staff reports on urban forestry operations, and updates on various working groups focused on landscape codes and housing. The commission also reviewed a state legislative proposal affecting tree preservation ordinances.
Key Decisions The commission began by approving the minutes from the previous meeting; Ed Macy abstained as he was not present at that prior session, while all other voting members voted in favor. The body then voted on three alternative compliance requests. The request for 16 Robert Street to reduce a required property line buffer from 20 feet to 6.7 feet passed unanimously. Similarly, the request for 144 Biltmore Avenue to reduce the number of required street trees due to narrow sidewalks and existing utility infrastructure also passed unanimously. However, the request for 225 Emma Road to use a standard for small maturing trees instead of large maturing trees to maximize solar access for a net-zero development was not voted on. An initial motion to approve failed to receive a second and was rescinded. A subsequent motion to deny the request was withdrawn by the mover in favor of a continuance. The applicant, Equinox Environmental, voluntarily withdrew the request to resubmit it after completing the Technical Review Committee process and providing additional information, such as solar access mapping. Finally, the commission unanimously appointed Zoe Hoyle as Vice Chair.
Discussion Highlights During the discussion of the 225 Emma Road request, a representative from Equinox Environmental explained that the project aims for net-zero homes and that using smaller street trees would prevent shading of solar panels. Commissioner Ed Macy stated that without solar access mapping information, he could not make a decision, noting that it would establish a bad precedent. He clarified that solar energy reduces the use of carbon but does not sequester it. Regarding the proposed changes to the Landscape Code (711-3), Commissioner Sharon Sumrall expressed concern about an exemption for vehicle use areas elevated by a berm, stating that in her experience, this would reduce the tree canopy. Staff member Chris Collins noted that the code does not yet have a council date and that discussions are ongoing regarding a green roofs provision. Chair Patrick Gilbert addressed State Senate Bill 317, which proposes exemptions from tree preservation ordinances for large workforce housing projects. He stated that the commission does not want any exemptions to Section 719, citing the hard work put into developing the current ordinance. Additionally, Urban Forester Keith Aiken reported that Duke Power indicated that the installation of more EV chargers will lead to more tree cutting due to higher voltage lines.
Community Input A resident with a net-zero home provided public comment during the 225 Emma Road discussion, stating, "I would just like to applaud what Nicholson's trying to do. I live in a net zero home... This is what's happening, and this is what has to happen." Members did not respond to this comment.
Follow-ups Several follow-up actions were agreed upon during the meeting. Staff member Chris Collins agreed to provide Chair Patrick Gilbert with the results of the ongoing GIS work for the Missing Middle Housing study. Urban Forester Keith Aiken agreed to email Jason Seifel of Equinox Environmental to schedule a meeting to discuss the resubmission of the 225 Emma Road request. Staff member Nancy agreed to send the meeting link to a member experiencing technical difficulties. Commissioner Ed Macy agreed to review Sharon Sumrall’s notes on the Landscape Code before they are sent to city staff and volunteered to join the Urban Forest Master Plan Fee-in-Lieu working group. Commissioner Karen Macneil agreed to organize meetings for the Appropriate Species List group. The Policy Working Group agreed to meet within the next two weeks to review the Chapter 20 comparison document before submitting it to city staff.
Impact These decisions and discussions impact how tree preservation and urban development are managed in Asheville. The approvals for 16 Robert Street and 144 Biltmore Avenue allow specific construction projects to proceed with reduced tree buffers or counts, balancing development needs with existing infrastructure constraints. The withdrawal of the 225 Emma Road request means that the net-zero housing project will not receive its requested tree standard change at this time, requiring the applicant to gather more data before a future decision. The ongoing work on the Landscape Code and the review of state legislation highlight the commission’s focus on maintaining canopy coverage and adapting regulations to new housing and energy trends.
Meeting Video & Transcript