Skip to main content

Urban Forestry Commission – May 2, 2023

May 2, 2023 at 1:00 PM

Recap readyAdd to calendar
Previous: Apr 4 meetingNext: Jun 6 meeting
  • 2 h 2 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

Urban Forestry Commission Meeting Recap: May 2, 2023

The Urban Forestry Commission of the City of Asheville convened on May 2, 2023, to address urban forestry operations, budget advocacy, and commission leadership. Dawn Chavez, Vice Chair and Executive Director of Asheville Greenworks, facilitated the meeting following the resignation of former Chair Amy Smith. The agenda included a review of alternative compliance cases, staff reports on tree management, and discussions regarding the upcoming fiscal year budget and federal grant opportunities.

Key Decisions and Votes The commission took several unanimous actions during the session. The minutes from the previous meeting were accepted by a 6-0 vote. The body approved an alternative compliance request for 191 Amboy Road, which sought reduced buffer plantings due to steep topography on an existing commercial site; this motion also passed 6-0. Additionally, the commission voted 6-0 to move the July meeting date to June 27. A significant portion of the meeting focused on funding for the Urban Forest Master Plan; the commission voted 6-0 to send a letter to City Council urging the inclusion of funding for the plan in the FY24 budget. To address a potential conflict of interest regarding her role at Asheville Greenworks, the commission voted 6-0 to recuse Dawn Chavez from votes on recommendations involving GreenWorks partnerships. Following this recusal, the commission voted 6-0 to urge the City of Asheville to partner with GreenWorks to secure funding from the federal Inflation Reduction Act (IRA) for the Urban Forest Master Plan. Finally, Cecil Bothwell nominated Patrick Gilbert to serve as Chair, with Zoe Hoyle seconding the motion. Patrick Gilbert abstained from voting, and the motion passed 5-0.

Discussion Highlights Staff provided a training on the alternative compliance process under the Unified Development Ordinance (UDO), explaining that the commission makes recommendations to the Planning Director regarding relief from landscaping requirements. Nancy Watford, Zoning and Stormwater Supervisor, clarified that the commission’s role is to recommend approval, approval with conditions, or denial of such requests. In the City Arborist Report, Mark Foster discussed emerald ash borer treatments, wind-related tree removals, and inspections of new plantings. He noted staffing challenges, stating, "I have one certified arborist who works for me, and he’s my lead climber. Good luck getting any other certified arborists who don’t want to work here at the city." Keith Aiken, the Urban Forester, reported on his ongoing education, work on the forest management plan, and efforts to standardize the recommended tree species list. Commissioner Cecil Bothwell commented on this effort, saying, "If you can resolve this [the recommended species list], you’ll be a hero." Staff also announced that Keith Aiken will transition to serving as the staff liaison to the Urban Forestry Commission by July.

Commissioner Patrick Gilbert discussed the intersection of "missing middle" housing initiatives with tree canopy preservation, noting potential state legislation that could exempt certain projects from landscaping ordinances. Kim Roney, the City Council Liaison, observed regarding the budget process, "It’s the first time that I’ve ever noticed that the council didn’t narrow the final decision... We still have some work to do." The commission also discussed the timeline for the revised landscaping code (Article 711-3), which is currently in the final stages of review before going to Planning & Zoning and City Council. Dawn Chavez shared that the group celebrated Arbor Day on April 29 by planting 100 trees at the Hardesty Lane Nursery, adding, "Keith, was there planting trees barefoot. I looked the other way, so I wouldn’t worry about liability issues."

Community Input No public comments were received during the designated comment period for the alternative compliance case or during the general public comment period.

Follow-Ups Staff agreed to discuss with the commission how to incorporate tree inventories into the alternative compliance process. Staff also agreed to follow up with the Parks Department and other city departments that plant trees to determine their oversight processes and whether certified arborists are involved. Staff agreed to invite the lead planner for the landscaping code to the June 6 meeting to discuss the draft with the commission. Regarding the federal grant, Dawn Chavez stated she has already emailed council members and the City Manager to advocate for participation. Commissioner Patrick Gilbert agreed to share a missing middle housing overview with Zoe Hoyle and other interested members, and they agreed to schedule a meeting to discuss the topic in depth.

Impact These decisions establish the commission’s leadership structure for the remainder of the year and set the stage for advocacy regarding the Urban Forest Master Plan. By urging City Council to include funding in the FY24 budget and partnering with GreenWorks for federal IRA grants, the commission is actively seeking resources to support long-term urban forestry goals. The approval of the alternative compliance request for 191 Amboy Road demonstrates the application of the UDO’s flexibility for sites with challenging topography. Furthermore, the transition of Keith Aiken to the role of staff liaison and the ongoing review of the landscaping code indicate continued administrative and regulatory development within the city’s urban forestry framework.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches