Sustainability Advisory Committee on Energy and the Environment – March 15, 2023
March 15, 2023 at 3:30 PM
- 1 h 30 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Key Decisions
The Sustainability Advisory Committee on Energy and the Environment met virtually on March 15, 2023. The committee took two formal actions during the session. First, a motion was made and seconded to approve the minutes from the February meeting; a roll call vote was taken, and the motion passed unanimously. Second, the committee voted on proposed changes to its bylaws and rules of procedure, which included updates to the committee’s name, conflict of interest provisions, and meeting frequency. A motion was made and seconded, and a roll call vote resulted in the unanimous adoption of these changes.
Discussion Highlights
The committee reviewed updates from three working groups. The Energy and Carbon Work Group discussed the Inflation Reduction Act and noted that a state program for rebates is currently pending due to a lack of Department of Energy guidance. The group also reviewed Duke Energy’s "Green Source Advantage Choice" program, which could increase solar purchasing opportunities. Member Michael Totten expressed concern regarding the use of Renewable Energy Certificates (RECs) in this context, stating, "There is no additionality in a REC now... And to rely on RECs is just greenwash. So I certainly hope the city and the county get rid of their idea of fulfilling their goals commitments with RECs."
The Community Resilience Work Group reported on the upcoming launch of a plastic survey, efforts to align goals with the Municipal Climate Action Plan (MCAP), and initiatives to simplify the climate resource guide. The Stormwater and Green Infrastructure Work Group discussed the implementation of the MCAP, cooperation with the riverfront redevelopment commission, and a 12-month stormwater utility study.
The committee also debated how to share information among working groups while complying with the Open Meetings Law. Member Sophie Mullinax suggested that sending email updates or reports after each meeting would not be intrusive and would help avoid operating in a silo. The Sustainability Department provided updates on the committee’s official name change, the presentation of the MCAP to the City Council’s Environment and Safety Committee, the launch of the single-use plastic survey, and the expansion of the food scraps drop-off program to two locations. City Council Liaison Maggie Elman commented on the MCAP presentation, noting, "It was awesome. It’s a great report... That balance between ambition and practicality was nicely struck."
Don Chavez, Executive Director of Asheville Greenworks, presented an update on the organization’s contract work with the city, including litter abatement, streamkeeper programs, waste reduction events, pollinator habitat certification, and urban forestry. Chavez shared the organization’s new strategic plan, stating, "Our new mission statement is to inspire, equip, and mobilize communities to create an equitable climate resilient future. We’ve adopted a new vision, which is a climate resilient future for all."
Follow-ups
Staff member Bridget Herring, Sustainability Director, agreed to follow up with the legal department regarding the feasibility of "silent observer" attendance at working group meetings to ensure compliance with the Open Meetings Law. Herring also agreed to ask the IT department if a platform exists that allows for silent, non-interactive observation of meetings, such as a "view-only" mode, to prevent accidental deliberation. Additionally, staff member Kiara Boulan agreed to provide follow-up information regarding the food scraps drop-off program, specifically concerning the hauler and the use of finished compost.
Impact
These decisions and discussions reflect the committee’s ongoing efforts to refine its operational structure and advance the city’s climate goals. The adoption of updated bylaws formalizes the committee’s new name and procedural rules. The review of the Municipal Climate Action Plan and the expansion of the food scraps program highlight active steps toward waste reduction and climate resilience. Furthermore, the discussion on information sharing aims to improve transparency and coordination among the committee’s various working groups, ensuring that community stakeholders have access to relevant updates on energy, resilience, and stormwater initiatives.
Meeting Video & Transcript