Skip to main content
  • 1 h 11 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

Historic Resources Commission Meeting Recap: December 14, 2022

The City of Asheville’s Historic Resources Commission (HRC) convened on December 14, 2022, to conduct evidentiary hearings for three properties within the city’s historic districts and to address administrative updates. The meeting began with the approval of the minutes from the previous November session. The Commission then reviewed requests for Certificates of Appropriateness (CAO) and preliminary subdivision approvals, concluding with discussions on upcoming presentations and subcommittee work.

Key Decisions The Commission made three unanimous decisions during the evidentiary hearings. First, for 60 Terrace Road in the Albemarle Park Historic District, the Commission approved and issued a CAO for the rebuilding of an existing retaining wall and paved area adjacent to an accessory structure. Second, for 15 Grindstaff Drive in the St. Dunstan’s Historic District, the Commission approved and issued a preliminary subdivision approval to divide a 0.98-acre lot into two lots of 0.39 acres and 0.59 acres. Third, for 74 Pearson Drive in the Montford Historic District, the Commission approved and issued a CAO for the replacement of nine vinyl windows with wood windows, replacement of rear concrete steps, replacement of front brick steps with concrete, extension of a gravel driveway, and removal of an invasive Tree of Heaven. This final approval included a condition that manufacturer specifications for the windows be submitted to staff for approval.

Discussion Highlights During the review of 60 Terrace Road, the applicant clarified that the paved area would be replaced with concrete to match existing materials, a choice made to comply with standards and avoid the need for a district amendment. For 15 Grindstaff Drive, staff reported no concerns regarding the lot layout, and the applicant noted plans to preserve large oak trees on the property during future development. The most extensive discussion occurred regarding 74 Pearson Drive, where the Commission agreed that 12-over-1 window configurations were most consistent with the original historic windows. The applicant agreed to amend the application to include the replacement of two additional vinyl windows on the side of the house. Staff also noted that the front brick steps were not original and that concrete was more consistent with the surrounding landscape.

In the administrative portion of the meeting, staff announced that the County Planning Director, Nate Pennington, would present an update on the county’s comprehensive plan in February or March. A staff member expressed happiness that the county had incorporated elements from the preservation plan into the comprehensive plan, hoping for potential future funding for the program. Additionally, a member remarked on the value of staff presenting to other boards, stating, "Historic resources just gets isolated... as you start to, or Alex starts to present to other boards and commissions, it's easier for people to see how these things fit in." When asked if the commission wanted more commissioners involved in subcommittee work next year, a staff member responded, "Yes. Yes, definitely a subcommittee. Subcommittee work should resume."

Community Input Public comment was recorded for two of the three agenda items. For 60 Terrace Road, a public commenter, identified as a resident of the property, stated their main concern was preserving a white oak tree on the lot, noting that arborists had recommended pruning and cabling rather than removal. When asked about the material for the paved area, the commenter stated they were indifferent between brick and concrete but would defer to the Commission’s judgment. In response, a staff member explained that while stained concrete is generally not allowed in other districts, brick is rarer in Albemarle Park; after confirming both materials are allowed, the applicant decided to proceed with concrete.

For 15 Grindstaff Drive, a public commenter, identified as a former owner assisting the current owner, asked about the level of architectural services required for the next phase of development. A staff member replied, "I would be your point person to talk you through all of that... I can just circle back with an email essentially what for a major work application packet we have a whole list of things that we require." The staff member also offered to provide a list of design professionals who have worked in historic districts. No public comments were recorded for the 74 Pearson Drive item.

Follow-ups Staff explicitly agreed to three follow-up actions. First, a staff member agreed to email the applicant for 15 Grindstaff Drive a detailed list of requirements for a major work application and information on design professionals. Second, a staff member agreed to follow up with the applicant for 74 Pearson Drive regarding the submission of window manufacturer specifications. Third, a staff member stated they would look into the history of a specific garage door if the owner requested replacement in the future.

Impact These decisions allow property owners in the Albemarle Park, St. Dunstan’s, and Montford Historic Districts to proceed with specific exterior modifications and lot divisions that align with historic preservation standards. The approval of the subdivision at 15 Grindstaff Drive facilitates the division of the property while preserving significant trees, and the window replacements at 74 Pearson Drive ensure that new materials match the historic character of the Montford district. The administrative updates highlight the Commission’s ongoing efforts to integrate historic preservation into broader city and county planning processes and to re-engage commissioners in subcommittee work.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches