Skip to main content
  • 1 h 4 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

Meeting Overview

On November 9, 2022, the City of Asheville Historic Resources Commission (HRC) convened to review applications for Certificates of Appropriateness (COA) within the Montford Historic District. The agenda focused on two primary construction projects: a new two-story primary structure and accessory dwelling unit (ADU) at 311 Cumberland Avenue, and exterior modifications at 75 Cherry Street. Additionally, the Commission adopted the minutes from the previous meeting and discussed upcoming community events, including the South Asheville Cemetery cleanup and the Asheville Holiday Parade.

Key Decisions

The Commission unanimously adopted the minutes from the October meeting. Regarding 311 Cumberland Avenue, the Commission unanimously approved the Certificate of Appropriateness. The approval included specific conditions requiring the submission of garage door specifications and any new stone for retaining wall repair for staff review and approval. Similarly, for 75 Cherry Street, the Commission unanimously approved the COA with the condition that wood door specifications must be submitted for staff review and approval.

Discussion Highlights

The review of 311 Cumberland Avenue marked the third iteration of this application, with discussions centering on revisions to the accessory structure’s roof form, driveway width, and retaining walls. Staff member Alex noted that the revised design "clearly reads... more of an accessory to the primary structure than either of the two proposals." Commissioner Will Hornaday commented that the current design is the "closest we're going to get with a structure of this size to be... meeting the... design criteria... for accessory structures." Chair Emily Kite discussed the trade-off regarding the roof pitch, stating, "My preference, I think the trade-off is worth it in this particular case because the language between the two I think it's much closer to each other."

For 75 Cherry Street, the project involved removing overgrown trees, replacing damaged basement siding, and constructing a two-story covered porch on the rear elevation. Staff member Alex suggested that a covered porch was more appropriate than a two-story deck, noting, "In the past when we've had requests come up for two-story decks we have said... it would be more appropriate to have a covered porch versus a deck." When discussing the shingles on the porch, a Commissioner suggested painting them instead of staining, stating, "I just think that it's we're extending more of the of an anomaly around the back." Staff member Alex also addressed concerns about a historic sleeping porch, noting, "I don't really think that this roof form or this structure is going to come over far enough to really mess with that [historic element]... I think it could come off and be restored in the future." Additionally, a Commissioner commented on the door widths, noting, "I think it's less funny when it's... [balanced]. Balance is better."

Follow-ups

A Commissioner explicitly agreed to follow up with the builder, Andrew, regarding the 75 Cherry Street project in the next few days. For 311 Cumberland Avenue, staff indicated that if issues arise during construction, such as with the retaining wall, the applicant should reach out to staff to determine next steps, which may include potential re-review.

Impact

These decisions allow for the continued development and renovation of properties within the Montford Historic District while ensuring compliance with historic preservation standards. The conditions attached to both approvals require specific material and design specifications to be reviewed by staff before work proceeds, providing a mechanism to ensure the final construction aligns with the Commission's design criteria.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches