Design Review Committee
September 16, 2021 at 12:30 PM
- 1 h 33 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Design Review Committee Meeting Recap: September 16, 2021
The City of Asheville Design Review Committee held a virtual meeting on September 16, 2021, to review three development projects in the downtown area. The committee also approved the minutes from its previous meeting on August 19, 2021, by a unanimous vote of 5-0.
Key Decisions and Votes The committee voted to recommend approval for all three projects presented, subject to specific conditions.
- 39 Patton Avenue: The committee unanimously recommended approval (5-0) for a restorative project on a late 1920s building. The motion, moved by Brian Moffitt and seconded by Robin Raines, included a condition that the applicant must work with staff to ensure 70% of the street-level facade consists of windows, doors, and other openings, meeting administration requirements for key pedestrian streets.
- 217 Hilliard Street: The committee recommended approval (4-1) for an infill, five-story building containing 80 units. The motion, moved by Brian Moffitt and seconded by Robin Raines, passed with Kim Hunter voting Nay. Conditions require the applicant to work with the tree planting working group to meet best practices for street trees and to preserve the existing granite curb as much as possible.
- 61 Biltmore Avenue: The committee recommended approval (5-0) for an eight-story hotel addition with 115 rooms. The motion, moved by Brian Moffitt and seconded by Robin Raines, passed with Ben Williamson absent for this specific vote. Conditions include reviewing the southern elevation at the corner of the private alley and Biltmore Avenue, reviewing best practices for tree planting guidelines, and appropriately addressing site lighting.
Discussion Highlights Significant debate occurred regarding the 217 Hilliard Street project, specifically concerning parking and housing affordability. Chair Jane Matthews noted that the lack of parking puts a burden on the city and adjacent neighborhoods, suggesting the issue might be brought to City Council for consideration. Regarding affordability, developer David Moritz clarified that the project is market-rate, though rents would currently fall below the 80% Area Median Income (AMI) qualification. Staff member Sasha Vrtunski explained that the city does not have affordable housing requirements unless the developer pursues a land use incentive grant, in which case agreements for affordable units are generally for 20 years.
For the 61 Biltmore Avenue hotel addition, discussions focused on the building’s facade. Member Brian Moffitt expressed that the corner of the building could use more articulation to express the building’s organization, even if the wall remains opaque. Architect Buck Lindsey responded that the team was open to this suggestion.
Community Input No live public comments were received for any of the three projects. For 217 Hilliard Street, the committee noted one email comment regarding parking; however, the chair stated that the committee does not have purview over parking policy.
Follow-ups Staff member Sasha Vrtunski agreed to return the following month with an updated status on the design guidelines, suggesting a "charrette" or workshop to identify major problems. Additionally, staff indicated they would work with the applicant for 61 Biltmore Avenue to provide more detail on the drawings regarding the southern elevation before the next review. Due to a temporary loss of quorum, the committee agreed to hold a short public meeting early the following week to finalize the vote on 61 Biltmore Avenue, which was subsequently completed.
Impact These decisions impact the physical development of Asheville’s downtown core. The approval of the 39 Patton Avenue project ensures the preservation and restoration of a historic building with specific transparency requirements for the streetscape. The 217 Hilliard Street project adds 80 residential units to the area, with conditions aimed at maintaining street tree health and historic curb features. The 61 Biltmore Avenue project expands hotel capacity with 115 new rooms, with conditions focused on improving the visual integration of the building at the alley corner and ensuring proper site lighting and tree planting.
Meeting Video & Transcript