Skip to main content

City Council Meeting - September 6, 2016

September 6, 2016 at 11:00 AM

  • 3 h 36 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

City Council Meeting Recap: September 6, 2016

The Asheville City Council convened on September 6, 2016, to address a comprehensive agenda spanning infrastructure, housing, public safety, and zoning. The session included routine recognitions, contract approvals, and several public hearings regarding development projects and sign ordinances. The council also adopted its 2016-17 Strategic Priorities and made appointments to various boards and commissions.

Key Decisions and Votes The council approved the remaining items on the consent agenda unanimously, after removing two specific contracts for separate discussion. In a 5-2 vote, the council approved a resolution to renew the agreement with the U.S. Department of Justice for a Drug Enforcement Agency (DEA) task force post. Similarly, the council voted 5-2 to approve a contract with Pinnacle Landscapes LLC for median maintenance.

Regarding development and zoning, the council unanimously approved several conditional use and zoning requests. These included a 70-unit, 100% affordable multifamily development at Bowcatcher Commons on Simpson Street, a rezoning request for a restaurant at 184 Newhawk Creek Road, and an amendment to the Aris Development on Patton Avenue to adjust residential and hotel unit mixes. The council also unanimously approved a conditional zoning request to split a parcel at 999 Caribou Road, with the condition that the remaining residential land be deeded to the Shiloh Community Association. Additionally, the council unanimously authorized the City Manager to negotiate with Tribute Companies for the 338 Hilliard Avenue property and adopted the 2016-17 Strategic Priorities. Board appointments were also made, with most passing unanimously, though the reappointment of Jim Muth to the Tourism Development Authority passed 6-1.

Discussion Highlights Significant debate occurred during the discussion of the DEA Task Force agreement. One council member cited the disproportionate impact of the "war on drugs" on people of color and those in poverty, stating they could not in good conscience vote to re-enter the agreement. Another council member referenced Portugal’s legalization of drug use as a model, arguing that the city should not participate with the DEA. Conversely, other members supported the agreement, noting the need for law enforcement resources.

On the Pinnacle Landscapes contract, one council member expressed concern about privatizing government work, stating a desire to see justification for why such services cannot be performed in-house. Regarding the Ingalls Markets signage hearing, council members emphasized that "the rules are the rules" and that carving out exemptions for a single company was inherently unfair. In response, the applicant offered to withdraw the application and resubmit a compliant version, leading to no final vote on the package as presented. A similar withdrawal occurred for a sign ordinance variance request for a business known as "Front of Bill," where the applicant withdrew the application after council comments.

Community Input Public comment was received on several items. During the DEA Task Force discussion, a public commenter supported legalization but urged the council to support police enforcement efforts to protect innocent women and children in their neighborhood. Another public commenter commended council members who spoke against the war on drugs and encouraged the council to contact the President to remove marijuana from Schedule I.

For the Bowcatcher Commons project, a public commenter spoke in favor of the development, suggesting that integrating monthly bus passes into rental costs could help extend transit lines. Another public commenter noted the project’s alignment with community goals and its provision for the Wilma Dykeman Greenway. Regarding the 999 Caribou Road project, a representative from the Shiloh Community Association supported the parking lot development and requested that the unused land be donated to the association for a resource center; this request was incorporated into the final motion. A property owner expressed concern about stormwater drainage but noted that the engineer assured him the buffer design would allow water to flow properly.

At the end of the meeting, a public commenter argued that Asheville should move to district elections, proposing specific geographic districts and a district for public housing residents. The Chair stated that the council anticipates a further conversation on district elections in the next couple of months, and a council member noted that in many districted cities, candidates are still elected citywide.

Follow-ups Staff and council members outlined several next steps. The City Manager stated that staff would seek help from the legal office to determine if wage rates can be included as a standard request in Requests for Proposals (RFPs) and would develop budget options for bringing contracted services, such as security and landscaping, in-house, beginning with Finance Committee review in the fall. Staff from the Transportation Department indicated they are working with the North Carolina Department of Transportation (NCDOT) to formalize an Aesthetics Committee and will continue to bring quarterly updates to the council. A subgroup is developing a list of bicycle, sidewalk, greenway, and transit improvements to present to NCDOT at a September 20 working group meeting.

For the Lee Walker Heights housing project, the Asheville Housing Authority stated they plan to meet with the North Carolina Housing Finance Agency this month to address feedback on their rejected application, intending to re-apply in January or explore the 4% tax credit program. Staff will prepare findings of fact and conclusions of law for the Bowcatcher Commons project for review at the next meeting. For the 338 Hilliard Avenue property, staff will negotiate terms with Tribute Companies and bring specific terms back to the Council for approval. Staff will also communicate the adopted strategic priorities to city departments and visit each board and commission in September and October. Finally, a council member requested a report from zoning enforcement on graffiti enforcement versus businesses.

Impact These decisions reflect the council's ongoing efforts to balance development with community needs, particularly in affordable housing and infrastructure. The approval of the Bowcatcher Commons and the Aris Development amendments supports the city's housing goals, while the conditions attached to the 999 Caribou Road project ensure community benefits through land donation. The debate over the DEA Task Force and the Pinnacle Landscapes contract highlights ongoing discussions about the role of government in public safety and the cost-effectiveness of outsourcing services. The adoption of strategic priorities and the commitment to review in-house service options signal a focus on long-term planning and fiscal responsibility.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches